I just put AppleCare+ on my 11 Pro, 60 days was also running out and I bit the bullet. Because I genuinely love it and should something bad ever happen to it physically, I want to make sure the coverage and service is there for it affordably. While I am generally a careful person, you never know what might happen tomorrow.
The 11 Pro has a lovely frosted glass finish that really does feel amazing in your hand, and now I really look forward to being able to actually use the phone completely naked on some days, knowing I have coverage should I drop it accidentally, but will still use a case in normal circumstances.
Other nice side effect - the 2 year coverage = I'm locking myself into my 11 Pro for 2 years and will not upgrade until the at least 2 years from now. And should something bad happen to it, especially if that sleek new battery degrades faster than expected (my Xs was at 86% after just 1 year eg), then I'm covered.