Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
So let me get this straight!

You're going to give the middle finger to the most valuable company in the world so you can sleep with the enemy, and Apple is suppose to help you with this process and let you make a seamless transition?

This is not a bug or an issue IMO. I honestly don't think they will even fix it, nor should they.

Wow! I dont understand why you take this so personally!

PS - Google is now the most valuable brand.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technolo...akes-Apple-as-worlds-most-valuable-brand.html
 
I really don't get why people use iMessage

There are tons of other messaging apps, and much better.

I live in a country where hardly anyone uses text messages.

WhatsApp is the standard. Other favorites are skype, facebook chat, line.
 
Why is this even being discussed as a "problem"? Apple should just have one recommendation to people facing this issue - "Buy an iPhone". I don't understand why Apple would have to go the extra mile to help users with competitor devices. If anything this proves staying within Apples ecosystem "Just Works". Why bother about those who choose to leave it? They ought to suffer the consequences. I don't see Apple bending backwards to make life easy for Windows users. :confused:

I don't know if you are serious or not, as you imply you are an Apple loyalist, yet this is 100% Apple-bashing. Apple is committed to a quality customer experience, and moving your phone number to another phone is part of the customer experience. So you are bad-mouthing Apple by implying that they would screw their customers intentionally. All quality companies that lose customers to the competition do everything in their power to win them back, and Apple is no exception. Doing that short-sighted "we'll destroy you, loser switcher" stuff you ascribe to them would be moronic, and no serious company would even think that way.
 
Nope, pretty sure there's an option to "send as SMS" when the iMessage gets bounced back as undeliverable. But you have to have the phone number of the person in order to send it as a SMS, and not just the apple id that iMessage uses to send messages.

You say this, but I've had a very hard time contacting my wife when she was out of the country recently because while she was abroad she didn't have data but all messages I was sending were instantly 'delivered' by iMessage (so quick I wasn't able to even hold down on the message for the pop-up 'Send as text message' option to appear).

What was happening was that because her iPad was still at home (somewhere) with WiFi available all my messages were being delivered there and nothing arrived on her phone abroad.

What I ended up having to do was disable WiFi, disable cellular data so the ONLY method of sending the message was by SMS. This was incredibly frustrating having to do this every time I wanted to send her a message.

While I'm technically-savvy enough to know to do this, your average joe does not. And this is between iOS devices - the same basic problem applies if you have one iOS device with iMessage enabled and are also using a non-iOS phone.
 
I dunno about your friends. But when I had an iPhone I usually had their iMessage information as well as a phone number. It's not that difficult just to use the phone number instead...

That's the big problem, it still thinks their phone number is associated with an iPhone so sends it as an iMessage instead of a text message.
 
So let me get this straight!

You're going to give the middle finger to the most valuable company in the world so you can sleep with the enemy, and Apple is suppose to help you with this process and let you make a seamless transition?

This is not a bug or an issue IMO. I honestly don't think they will even fix it, nor should they.

You sir, win the prize for post of the week.. I congratulate you.. you win "the internet's"..
 
Android users can't send you an iMessage. It seems that you have a problem with regular SMS.

People have been saying that when you switch from iPhone to some Android phone or another phone, iMessage still somehow interferes and makes SMS not work properly because of iMessage.
 
Why is this even being discussed as a "problem"? Apple should just have one recommendation to people facing this issue - "Buy an iPhone". I don't understand why Apple would have to go the extra mile to help users with competitor devices. If anything this proves staying within Apples ecosystem "Just Works". Why bother about those who choose to leave it? They ought to suffer the consequences. I don't see Apple bending backwards to make life easy for Windows users. :confused:

They ought to suffer the consequences for Apple's own software not working properly?
 
This has grown as a PR issue, so Apple is going to fix it.
When it was only "a few customers" problem, Apple ignored it.
It has been a problem since iOS 5.
It's only a matter of numbers. Middle finger to customers, until news start spreading around
 
You say this, but I've had a very hard time contacting my wife when she was out of the country recently because while she was abroad she didn't have data but all messages I was sending were instantly 'delivered' by iMessage (so quick I wasn't able to even hold down on the message for the pop-up 'Send as text message' option to appear).

What was happening was that because her iPad was still at home (somewhere) with WiFi available all my messages were being delivered there and nothing arrived on her phone abroad.

What I ended up having to do was disable WiFi, disable cellular data so the ONLY method of sending the message was by SMS. This was incredibly frustrating having to do this every time I wanted to send her a message.

While I'm technically-savvy enough to know to do this, your average joe does not. And this is between iOS devices - the same basic problem applies if you have one iOS device with iMessage enabled and are also using a non-iOS phone.

Actually, there's an option under messaging to disassociate iMessage with any email addresses and thus stop iMessage from sending messages to that app. I'll give you that your average user may not know how to do that, but honestly only takes a little common sense and familiarity with how iMessage works to know you'd have to do something like that. The problem is that they tried to combine SMS and iMessage, which while convenient, muddied how the process works.

I'd bet a majority of people would know that you can't send an email to a landline because they obviously use different technology and aren't compatible. Yet iMessage and SMS are a similar situation and somehow it never enters their mind to evaluate their situation and fix whatever settings they need to fix.
 
So let me get this straight!

You're going to give the middle finger to the most valuable company in the world so you can sleep with the enemy, and Apple is suppose to help you with this process and let you make a seamless transition?

This is not a bug or an issue IMO. I honestly don't think they will even fix it, nor should they.

So let me get this straight.

You're going to give the middle finger to your ex-girlfriend you broke up with because you weren't satisfied of your relationship to sleep with your new girlfriend, and she should let you do just that?

This isn't a problem IMO. I honestly think she has all right to rule your life and decide who you can see or who can reach you.


/s (people, seriously)
 
Oh and Google is now the most valuable company so there's that.

When you say "most valuable company" most think of stock market cap, which is completely objective. Apple is way over Google here.

AAPL: $523 B
GOOG: $367 B

My guess is you are referring to a brand survey from some marketing company, which is 100% subjective.
 
Is it really Apple's responsibility to redirect our messages? I think with having an account with iCloud or the iMessage services it is the consumers responsibility to properly deactivate Apple "stuff" when switching over to a non-Apple device.

Maybe I don't know enough about it. Looking forward to what everyone thinks.
 
Is it really Apple's responsibility to redirect our messages? I think with having an account with iCloud or the iMessage services it is the consumers responsibility to properly deactivate Apple "stuff" when switching over to a non-Apple device.

Maybe I don't know enough about it. Looking forward to what everyone thinks.

you don't know enough about it. Please read through the numerous threads already beating this subject to death. It's Apple not properly disassociating your phone number with iMessage if you decide to change to an android, windows, or blackberry phone. Even when a customer decides to make a switch and turns off iMessage first, the bug is that Apple still thinks your number belongs to iMessage when it doesn't, causing the switcher to miss text messages from other iPhone users.

I'm guessing you haven't read all 3 pages yet in this thread and missed this post by itpromike, which helps explain it as well :)

https://forums.macrumors.com/posts/19133229/
 
I do not really know the extent of the imessage problem, but aren't most issues b.c people forget to turn imessage off? I wouldn't really call that a glitch.

it's a lot more than that.
For example, say I have my UK sim card. I switch to a German sim card with a german number. My iphone updates and uses the german number for iMessage. You would guess that if one particular iphone switches number, apple would be smart enough to assume that the previous number was disconnected grom imessage, right?

WRONG, people write to your UK number and you won't get those. What's worse, it will say that hte mssage was actually RECEIVED.

Received by whom? GOD?

----------

So let me get this straight!

You're going to give the middle finger to the most valuable company in the world so you can sleep with the enemy, and Apple is suppose to help you with this process and let you make a seamless transition?

This is not a bug or an issue IMO. I honestly don't think they will even fix it, nor should they.

it's a bug when it happens even when you keep your iphone but switch sim cards !!!!

----------

Why is this even being discussed as a "problem"? Apple should just have one recommendation to people facing this issue - "Buy an iPhone". I don't understand why Apple would have to go the extra mile to help users with competitor devices. If anything this proves staying within Apples ecosystem "Just Works". Why bother about those who choose to leave it? They ought to suffer the consequences. I don't see Apple bending backwards to make life easy for Windows users. :confused:

Once again, this problem faces also loyal apple users that for whatever reason have to swtich sim cards (i.e. when travelling).

Not a good idea to tell me that my problem is not a bug :)
I've had iphones since 2008.
 
The problem is that Apple is not your telephone service provider, so there is no way for them to know, automatically, that you no longer are using that phone with that number. So, "what the heck", how is Apple supposed to even know they "should have NOTHING" to do with the number unless YOU tell them? YOU have to de-register your phone with their service.


Okay bro, send me a link to the instructions Apple has posted to resolve this issue.....

Butter it up all you want, they missed an edge case.

----------

Since this has been an issue since iOS 5 the sales people who were chasing the extra commission of a SPIFFd non-iPhone are to blame for this getting out of hand. A good sales person knows his product and how to give the customer the best experience with their new product. Therefore if a customer was switching from an iPhone to competing platform, the first question to ask after finding if the customer wants to migrate photos and contacts is do they use Apple's iMessage feature (ie do you get Blue text balloons when you text other iPhone users?). If so, before switching the SIM, the salesperson should help the customer go into settings and turn off the iMessage feature and then send a test text to a known iPhone contact to verify that iMessage is disabled, indicated by the Green text balloon. This simple effort by the sales staff should have eliminated the majority of the defecting iPhone users text receipt issues after it was initially discovered.

And the people who do not buy in store ? Do they blame themselves ??

Does this problem affect people switching between android, windows and blackberry?? No. It's apple fault and not a sales persons responsibility

----------

Why is this even being discussed as a "problem"? Apple should just have one recommendation to people facing this issue - "Buy an iPhone". I don't understand why Apple would have to go the extra mile to help users with competitor devices. If anything this proves staying within Apples ecosystem "Just Works". Why bother about those who choose to leave it? They ought to suffer the consequences. I don't see Apple bending backwards to make life easy for Windows users. :confused:

Wow just wow...... So your suggesting Stockholm syndrome ;) wow
 
Nope, pretty sure there's an option to "send as SMS" when the iMessage gets bounced back as undeliverable. But you have to have the phone number of the person in order to send it as a SMS, and not just the apple id that iMessage uses to send messages.

Problem is, messages appear as DELIVERED even though no ios device/mac computer received it !!!!
 
Google Hangouts! It's what I use. Cross platform for both mobile and desktop. If you use Chrome on your desktop, you can install Hangouts as a desktop extension so it behaves like a standalone messaging app.

I have that too. But my friends don't hop on that to message me as often.
 
This is the "eco system" of Apple..

You use their services,,, they stuff it up... customers pay the price....


Give me old un-reliable SMS any-day....


It may be old fashioned, but at least it never breaks, not much. :rolleyes:
 
I don't really the problem. As long as you stay fully in Apple's "razor-wired walled garden", everything's fine. :):apple:
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.