Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster


Smart home device manufacturer Aqara today launched the Thermostat Hub W200, a new Matter-enabled thermostat that comes with several features that set it apart from existing smart thermostat options.

aqara-thermostat-w200.jpg

The W200 is Aqara's first thermostat created for North America, and I've been testing two of them for the last couple of months prior to launch. The W200 is a thermostat, but it's also a presence sensor and it serves as a hub for other Aqara and Matter devices with Thread and Zigbee integration.

Along with those features, the W200 supports Adaptive Temperature and Clean Energy Guidance, two HomeKit features that Apple added in iOS 26. Adaptive Temperature intelligently adjusts the thermostat when you leave the house, arrive back home, or sleep to save energy. Clean Energy Guidance adjusts electricity usage when energy sources are less clean, timing heating or cooling to use cleaner energy when possible.

The W200 has a squircle design with rounded edges, and it's a clean look that's more square than Ecobee and larger than Nest. The interface features large text for the temperature, and it displays the time when it's not active. The temperature can be controlled directly on the thermostat using the touchscreen, and all of the controls are also available in menus accessed with swipe gestures. The display does pick up fingerprints, and the fingerprints are noticeable on the glossy surface.

aqara-w200-thermostat-wall.jpg

I replaced two Nest thermostats with the W200 thermostats from Aqara, and because they arrived just before I happened to have a HVAC checkup scheduled, I had them installed by the HVAC company I use. I could have self-installed and saved some money since I was going from one smart thermostat to another and the wiring was the same. Taking a picture of the existing wiring and mirroring that after swapping in the new thermostat would have worked fine. The worst part of swapping from Nest to the Aqara W200 was the different base plate shape. The W200 has a smaller base plate, so there are unpainted edges on the wall that I still haven't fixed.

I have two heat pumps, one that's single stage and one that's dual stage. The dual stage heat pump operates as single stage because it's controlled by the onboard computer, so there's nothing too fancy in my setup. The W200 works with heat pumps (electric and geo-thermal), along with furnaces, boilers, and other heat sources.

There's a mmWave radar in the W200 that recognizes when a person is in the room and when it is being approached. The display on the thermostat activates when someone comes close, and the sensor is also used for activating heating and cooling schedules through the Aqara app and for Adaptive Temperature based on whether someone is home, or even in the room the thermostat is in.

The Aqara app has its own smart schedules that can be enabled that are distinct from Adaptive Temperature, but you have to choose between Apple Home control or the Aqara app. I tried both, but preferred the Adaptive Temperature interface because it was less complicated. Adaptive Temperature is basically a home or away setting, while Aqara has different time of day options. You can choose neither and control the temperature manually, ask Siri to change the temperature, or set up HomeKit automations based on time of day or other HomeKit devices. There are a lot of control options, so the W200 will do what you need, whether that's something simple or a complicated schedule. You will need a full Apple Home setup with an Apple Matter hub (HomePod or Apple TV) to use the W200 with HomeKit.

aqara-app-settings.jpg

I don't know how often most people change their interior temperatures, but mine is typically static. I work from home and live in North Carolina, where it gets humid. In the summer, I have to run the AC to keep it from getting too humid for my wood floors, and in the winter, it at least has to be warm enough for my plants, and those things need to happen whether I'm home or not. Heat pumps are more efficient at a steady temperature, so I'm not doing things like turning down the heat at night. Adaptive Temperature and all the options for changing heating and cooling throughout the day are aimed at people who have furnaces and can make better use of the electricity savings, but I do appreciate the scheduling for occasions where I do need to adjust temperature frequently. If you have a system where time-based changes result in electricity savings, you'll get the most out of the W200.

aqara-apple-home-app.jpg

Aqara could benefit from simplifying some of its products, but the company seems to focus on making a huge variety of options available so customers can pick and choose how they want to use a device. Aqara's smart locks support unlocking with fingerprints, NFC, smartphones, codes, and more, and that same versatility is available with the W200.

aqara-adaptive-energy-w200.jpg

I did run into an issue with the W200 during testing, and it's still not resolved. The thermostat has a "Min Compressor Outdoor Working Temp" that can't be set below 20 degrees Fahrenheit. That suggests to me that it switches to auxiliary heat at that point, and that's not what I want it to be doing. Newer heat pumps for cold climates can operate below 20 degrees, and I want to minimize aux heating because mine is electric and expensive. I asked Aqara about this, and they suggested turning off the "Enable to work with heat pump" feature in the Aux settings, but their setup flow says to enable the aux and heat pump setting if the auxiliary heat is electric. The app says "Please follow the prompts to select, otherwise the machine will be damaged," when directing me to select aux heat settings, and since I am not an HVAC expert, I don't want to choose the wrong option.

The auxiliary heating and compressor temperature wording is unclear in the app and on the thermostat, and communicating with Aqara did not help. My HVAC tech said I might not want to use this thermostat because I can't set the compressor to continue to run at a lower temp. On an Ecobee thermostat, there is a setting to minimize auxiliary heat usage, and the compressor lockout can be disabled, but I don't have those settings on the W200. Aqara said the heat pump wording in the app will be updated in the future, but I'm still not sure the thermostat is giving users adequ... Click here to read rest of article

Article Link: Aqara W200 Thermostat Launches With Apple Adaptive Temperature and Clean Energy Support
 
  • Wow
Reactions: Z-4195
Adaptive Temperature intelligently adjusts the thermostat when you leave the house, arrive back home, or sleep to save energy.
Much like it takes more energy to spin a conventional hard drive up and down than it takes to keep it in motion, it actually takes more energy to enact a temperature change than to maintain an existing temperature. Keep in mind it's not just the air temperature that has to be acted upon, but the temperature of all the mass (furniture and other belongings) inside a home too (they all act as heat sinks).

If this is a vacation home or just someplace you're at on the weekend I can see this being useful, but for daily-living I've-gone-to-work you're going to waste power moving the temp up and down inside the home to suit your arrival.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zzu
I'm looking for one of these... but as a jilted first adopter of the U400 smart lock.... I'll wait this one out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zzu
Great review Juli, thanks! I have to replace my original Nests for a similar HVAC setup...
 
does anyone actually like their thermostat adjusting itself? I have my Ecobee programmed through HomeKit to do what I want when I want it
I mean that depends on how far it goes. My Ecobee adjusts based on whether someone is home or not. I suppose the biggest difference is that this can adapt based on what room you are in. So if you have a huge house you may not want it all heated or cooled to the same temperature as the room you've decided to spend the entire day (or night) in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: aloyouis
I mean that depends on how far it goes. My Ecobee adjusts based on whether someone is home or not. I suppose the biggest difference is that this can adapt based on what room you are in. So if you have a huge house you may not want it all heated or cooled to the same temperature as the room you've decided to spend the entire day (or night) in.
Exactly! I also like the future that adjust the temperature in a particular room based on the humidity. If it’s more humid, it feels warmer so it can run at a lower temperature. So far it’s been about six months and we have noticed no uncomfortableness when it does this.
 
  • Love
Reactions: alexandr
Exactly! I also like the future that adjust the temperature in a particular room based on the humidity. If it’s more humid, it feels warmer so it can run at a lower temperature. So far it’s been about six months and we have noticed no uncomfortableness when it does this.
Oh, that's awesome, so I take it you've been pioneering this adaptive temperature thang? 🙂
 
Much like it takes more energy to spin a conventional hard drive up and down than it takes to keep it in motion, it actually takes more energy to enact a temperature change than to maintain an existing temperature. Keep in mind it's not just the air temperature that has to be acted upon, but the temperature of all the mass (furniture and other belongings) inside a home too (they all act as heat sinks).

If this is a vacation home or just someplace you're at on the weekend I can see this being useful, but for daily-living I've-gone-to-work you're going to waste power moving the temp up and down inside the home to suit your arrival.
I'm pretty sure there are studies that show you save money by not heat/cooling your house all day when you are not there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kissaragi
I mean that depends on how far it goes. My Ecobee adjusts based on whether someone is home or not. I suppose the biggest difference is that this can adapt based on what room you are in. So if you have a huge house you may not want it all heated or cooled to the same temperature as the room you've decided to spend the entire day (or night) in.
Ecobee has room senors and heats/cools base on the rooms that are occupied, does Aqara have room senors?
 
not sure if anyone in here knows the answer but:

Shouldn't you always leave your air conditioner/heater running at all times (with the temperature being within a range), versus having it shut on/off?

I remember a technician who came over once said its better on my unit to have it always on and try to stay within a range, versus turning it off and then on.

Reason I ask the feature in this new Aqara says "Adaptive Temperature", does that mean it can potentially shut off my unit if its at the targeted temp?
 
Ecobee has room senors and heats/cools base on the rooms that are occupied, does Aqara have room senors?
I know, I've got them but are they adaptive? I haven't seen how that works in that way (not saying it doesn't). Yes Aqara has them too.
 
"created for North America" - what does that mean? US only or does that include Canada? Can it do temps in Celsius?

Probably a hedging way to say that the clean energy function may not work properly outside the US due to unavailable data.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.