Toggle sidebar Toggle sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Are students seen as not as smart...

Is a student seen as smarter if they use more punctionation?

  • Yes

    Votes: 12 50.0%

  • No

    Votes: 12 50.0%
  • Total voters
    24
waloshin

waloshin

macrumors 68040
Original poster
Are students seen as not as smart if they use shorter sentences, therefore, eliminating the need to much punctuation?

Are students seen as smarter if they use commas, semi colons instead of writing shorter sentences?
 
waloshin said:
Are students seen as not as smart if they use shorter sentences, therefore, eliminating the need to much punctionation?

Are students seen as smarter if they use commas, semi colons instead of writing shorter sentences?
Click to expand...

They might be seen as not as smart if they shorten their sentences by leaving out words like "use" or "and" when they're appropriate.
 
what the hell is "punctionation?"

these threads are worse than mine.

edit: nice ninja edit

edit 2: learn some "punctuation" in your sentence ... "commas, semicolons [sic]."

:facepalm:
 
It depends. Gratuitously long sentences never did anyone any good, however too short and simplistic sentences can make it harder to convey an elaborate point without coming across as talking down to your reader. I'd say good texts generally combine both long and short sentences to keep the writing interesting. In short, mix it up! 😉
 
acidfast7 said:
what the hell is "punctionation?"

these threads are worse than mine.

edit: nice ninja edit

edit 2: learn some "punctuation" in your sentence ... "commas, semicolons [sic]."

:facepalm:
Click to expand...

Should be punctuation ,but I cannot change the poll.
 
I've seen a lot of student submissions for assignments. The short answer is, yes. The long answer is holy crap yes. For forums or texting no. But if you are emailing your professor it would be a good idea to at least spell check.
 
acidfast7 said:
these threads are worse than mine.
Click to expand...

quote of the year.


And no, students are not "smarter" because they use more punctuation. In fact, that probably means you have run-on sentences, and would be better off breaking them up. You don't look smarter by having a one run-on sentence paragraph.
 
Another Waloshin thread
 

Attachments

  • I looked like Jonny Depp.png
    I looked like Jonny Depp.png
    197.5 KB · Views: 96
I would say that, while writing in a style which features long sentences isn't inherently difficult, it does have the effect of looking more sophisticated, hereby increasing the perceived level of english of the person, or in the case of a native speaker, its perceived level of intelligence; in no case, however, does it show any correlation since all one needs to write in such a style is some time, and to use it efficiently.

TL;DR: not in college. 😉
 
I think a series of short to moderately long sentences that can convey a complicated idea succinctly is ideal. Just because the sentence is short does not mean the vocabulary used needs to be limited. It is the combination of short sentences with an unsophisticated vocabulary that I believe conveys this sense of "un-smart" in today's students.

waloshin - - acidfast7

Too early to tell.
 
I think you should review your posts before you post them so you can correct your spelling and other mistakes.
😉 Just a thought...
 
I have multiple arguments from people when they ask me to review their papers and first complaint I had was it had to much cap fluf words. There is a time and place for fluf but not in research or technical documents. Those are to the point and use that style of writing.
Emails fall under the technical writing format and when I read some fluffy fill emails it really felt like the person was trying to cover something.
 
I remember having some old school "by the book" professor - bow-tie and all - freshman year. He said something along the lines of "Smart people talk about ideas, intelligent people explain their ideas in such a way that anyone can understand them."

I always kept that in mind when writing, whether it was a one pager or a 35 page paper. I must admit, it did sometimes make meeting page requirements difficult at first, but I found out that if your paper has 10 pages of substance in an 8 page paper, professors didn't mind (except one strict formatting freak I had, but at least he knew his standards so he kept page limits lower).
 
I don't care how much punctuation you use. I care if I can understand your writing.

A secondary benefit is enjoying reading it and not cringing at stupid mistakes, punctuation, or otherwise annoying stylistic quirks.
 
If you want to come off as not dumb to your professors, simply write properly punctuated and grammatically correct [insert language that you're trying to communicate in here].

Incidentally, I've never heard of the verb "to much."
 
mobilehaathi said:
It is his latest refrain in wacky threads. I think he finds it clever.
Click to expand...

When a forum full of people discusses the benefits of a Keurig, discussion of the finer culinary points is not appropriate.

----------

To contribute directly to the narrative of the thread:

A positive correlation exists between judicious punctuation usage and perceived intellect.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back