I have to return my Max because the OLED aggravates my eyes and migraine. And there were some connectivity issues.
Putting aside my migraine problem that many people fortunately do not have to consider, the display on my particular Max was gorgeous and a worthy upgrade. The camera showed improvements I was interested in. It handled tough lighting situations better than my 8 Plus does. It has stereo audio recording ability. Oddly, someone coming from a 7 Plus might not notice a huge upgrade, because in my observation, the 7 Plus did a much nicer job than the 8/8 Plus and X at NOT obscuring detail in blown out highlights
I did appreciate that the display itself as well as the camera both offer higher dynamic range than my 8 Plus does.
The stereo sound from the speakers was incredible. Apple outdid themselves there. I will sorely miss that beautiful surround sound effect I enjoyed in the one Amazon Prime movie I got to watch on it (Regarding Henry).
Sadly, call quality was still atrocious. Possibly worse than my 8 Plus offers, and that’s no prince either. But there is a chance that will be fixed at some point once the engineers finish their trouble shooting. There’s a whole thread about it and I don’t think anything is quite figured out or resolved yet.
I did enjoy having extra screen real estate. If I could keep it I certainly would. I’m very sad I have to send it back to Apple.
As for justifying the price, well if I were still my 35 year old self struggling on a budget, no, I suppose I could not justify the price and would hang on to an 8 Plus as long as I could.
But I’m 52. How many more iPhone generations do I have left to enjoy? If I end up with osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis like my mom, (and I already have autoimmune disease so it’s not looking good for me) I won’t be able to use an iPhone physically even if I can handle it cognitively. So, I went for it because right now I can afford it and I don’t have a huge window of enjoying these devices. And they certainly didn’t exist when I was in my prime. I had a honking huge Nokia and an ugly pager instead.
Anyway I’m looking forward now to an XR. It’s not the same. But I’m sure I’ll have fun with it. Just trying to decide on a color is fun.