Yes this exactly the point of the information I am putting together. If you have read Ben Goldacre's book Bad Science this follows on in a similar vein but with more of a focus on making clear what is and is not known.
Incidentally if you have not read Bad Science I highly recommend it. From your posts I'm sure you would love it.
It is a noble endeavour.... but perhaps you are re-inventing the wheel here?
Has this topic not already been covered extensively? Maybe it would be more useful to simply create a catalogue of links that relate to what are trying to do?