Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Carrier AT&T 2yr contract or NEXT?
- Thread starter thatappleguytoday
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
After all my calculations, I have come to figure out this. If you always have one line to upgrade in your plan every year, 2 year contract works. If you are on individual plan, then sorry, tough
Assumptions:
16GB phone
Mobile Share Plan
ATT next - one year - 32.5*12 + 15*12 = 570
Contract -199 +40*12+ 40(upgrade fee) = 720
Sell Contract Phone for ~ 350-400 - Final price for contract - 320 - 380.
You will come out minimum 190 cheaper, max it can go to 250.
This is just for one year, if you are like me who gets new phone every year.
Assumptions:
16GB phone
Mobile Share Plan
ATT next - one year - 32.5*12 + 15*12 = 570
Contract -199 +40*12+ 40(upgrade fee) = 720
Sell Contract Phone for ~ 350-400 - Final price for contract - 320 - 380.
You will come out minimum 190 cheaper, max it can go to 250.
This is just for one year, if you are like me who gets new phone every year.
You could sell it now either way couldn't you? And then just use the money to defray the monthly Next costs. I'm kind of in the same boat, I'm used to selling mine every year and use an upgrade from another line to upgrade every year, but now with mobile share and Next I'm intrigued. I sold my 5s for $350, and if i do Next I can upgrade every year without losing the $25 discount on another line or paying the $40 upgrade fee, but I no longer have phone to sell every year either, its a tough call.
----------
Yes but you have to pay the other year for the other line at the higher fee once you extend the contract. That is to say, you're on the hook for $40/month for 2 years regardless, and the same with the other line the next year, with Next you're always at $15/month.
Last edited:
Something to consider....
With contract pricing, your cost to cancel AT&T service while keeping your phone is $325, and $0 if you switch to T-Mobile (which reimburses ETFs). With NEXT, you've got to pay off the cost of the phone.
T-Mobile does not pay NEXT fees.
With contract pricing, your cost to cancel AT&T service while keeping your phone is $325, and $0 if you switch to T-Mobile (which reimburses ETFs). With NEXT, you've got to pay off the cost of the phone.
T-Mobile does not pay NEXT fees.
Contract for me. Never giving up "unlimited/5GB LTE" for $30. Plus I end up virtually getting my subsidized phone for free after I sell it 2 years later.
Maybe im missing something but why is every at&t employee telling me to not go next and keep my grandfathered data plan and save $50/mo.
Next is a HUGE ripoff......If you want to pay for your phone twice and then not keep it go ahead.
http://www.theverge.com/2013/7/16/4528404/att-next-phone-upgrade-plans-a-huge-ripoff
http://www.theverge.com/2013/7/16/4528404/att-next-phone-upgrade-plans-a-huge-ripoff
If you don't have money at all and the only way you can pay for the iphone is by next,
than know the cost, by the time you finish the pay you paid full retail price.
so ATT or any other company, don't do you free gift
This is outdated information. NEXT is an Interest free loan that gives you a lot of flexibility. The overall cost completely depends on what plans you have, what you switch to, and what device you want. For me, switching to Next costs maybe $25/year more, but I can upgrade with no hoops when I want and I don't have to pony up $500 up front for my top of the line device. Not that I couldn't but if AT&T wants to give me an interest free loan I'll take it.
Now I'm torn...I wasn't considering NEXT until I read this...
I have a single line, FAN account with 17% discount. Mobile Share Value Plan 2GB. After discounts my total bill is about $63...so far I've been upgrading every year or so, paying out of pocket and selling my previous phone.
I have a single line, FAN account with 17% discount. Mobile Share Value Plan 2GB. After discounts my total bill is about $63...so far I've been upgrading every year or so, paying out of pocket and selling my previous phone.
Sorry for the second post...
I can do NEXT right now for full price of $749, or 2 year contract for $549.
In twelve months i can do it all over again either with NEXT or 2 year contract.
If I don't care about being under contract am I better off with the lower price and the contract?
I can do NEXT right now for full price of $749, or 2 year contract for $549.
In twelve months i can do it all over again either with NEXT or 2 year contract.
If I don't care about being under contract am I better off with the lower price and the contract?
Yep - you get the same plan pricing whether you pay up front or pay via NEXT but the latter allows you to do so via interest free payments with no real contract other than that you agree to buy the phone out at full price if you want out early - the same cost as if you paid up front.
For me it is because I have an unlimited data plan and would not qualify for the monthly NEXT discount. However, people on that use NEXT and are on AT&T's new plans would receive a discount off their plan each month which is a good thing for some people.
I agree. I don't think it is a ripoff if you understand how it works.
1. you're not on a contract, so paying full price sounds about right!
2. I am getting additional discounts on my plan. I don't have a grandfathered plan.
3. I get to keep my phone after 20 months or 12.
4. Payment plans are feasible for some people. I can pay for my phone outright, but I'd rather invest it or use it for my Disney World trip.
I'm just dreading the higher bill each month. They said I can pay if off early if I wanted to, which is a plus! I'm still researching, got to make sure I'm going to make a decision I can stick with.
Why is taking a 0% loan with no strings a ripoff vs. spending your own cash up front?
Its not outdated. AT&T is still charging the subsidy behind the scenes.
You people really think this is in the benefit of the customer. Plaaaaaeeese!
Well, to be honest, if you do the next plan and you keep upgrading your phone every year, then you are definitely paying a premium to do so... But if you keep the phone the 2 years of time, your no better off than if you were to buy it outright and keep it for two years. It benefits customers who plan on keeping the phone. If your upgrading every year, it's mutually benefiting both sides, as AT&T profits from it, but you are also getting new phones quicker than you were on the subsidy model.