I early terminated my contract with AT&T last billing period and was told that I would incur a 125.00 ETR...I was good with that as I hardly ever use the phone and still had 13 months left..My question is why on earth would I have to pay a communication tax on a ETR..?? The bill had come to 139.00 with the tax..Is it just my area or nationwide for a tax on a ETR..??
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
AT&T Early Termination Fee Question
- Thread starter Mac N Tosh
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Maybe legally the ETF counts as prepaying a portion of your remaining bills which would have had the tax? Or they are just out to screw you because you are leavng
I wish I had an answer for you, but--as a former CSR for a wireless carrier--I can tell you that there is taxes upon taxes on a wireless bill. Additionally, many of the taxes are specific to your location of residence.
The best thing I can tell you is to call a rep but AT$T has crappy customer service, so good luck with that. Actually, their CS is probably the reason you asked on the forum instead of calling in the first place, so I feel your pain.
Good luck and don't forget to share afterwards.
The best thing I can tell you is to call a rep but AT$T has crappy customer service, so good luck with that. Actually, their CS is probably the reason you asked on the forum instead of calling in the first place, so I feel your pain.
Good luck and don't forget to share afterwards.
I wish I had an answer for you, but--as a former CSR for a wireless carrier--I can tell you that there is taxes upon taxes on a wireless bill. Additionally, many of the taxes are specific to your location of residence.
The best thing I can tell you is to call a rep but AT$T has crappy customer service, so good luck with that. Actually, their CS is probably the reason you asked on the forum instead of calling in the first place, so I feel your pain.
Good luck and don't forget to share afterwards.
Will try them again, tomorrow...!! Thanks tho !
Customers Service says they cannot discount a tax ..My response was, that in their own contract it says taxes will be collected on reoccurring monthly charges. An ETF is a one time penalty for canceling the contract, not a re occurring monthly charge, She agreed, and responded "We cannot discount a tax". I asked her if she could discount the ETF by 17.49 and she said......."NO". !!!
There ya have it...
But she did say.." Anything else I can do for you..?"
There ya have it...
But she did say.." Anything else I can do for you..?"
You're arguing that you shouldn't be paying a tax? Its not like AT&T will keep it.
They pay the taxes to the gov't. Arguing that you shouldn't be paying the tax is a bit pointless. I mean you state that you're not too upset about the amount of the ETF but you're making a federal case about the tax?
They pay the taxes to the gov't. Arguing that you shouldn't be paying the tax is a bit pointless. I mean you state that you're not too upset about the amount of the ETF but you're making a federal case about the tax?
I was arguing the tax should not be applied..As this was not a rec-occurring charge, but a penalty for contact cancellation. No communication(s) were used, why would there be a communications tax...The phone has not been disconnected for the past two months..
I think that tax is for general communications because you are paying an ETF to a communications company.
Well again, AT&T is just the conduit funneling the payments to the government. If you want to raise a complaint, lodge a complaint with the FCC or FTC
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 3_1_3 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/528.18 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/4.0 Mobile/7E18 Safari/528.16)
I think it's ridiculous that these wireless carriers can get away with adding a tax on to the ETF, but they all do it.
I think it's ridiculous that these wireless carriers can get away with adding a tax on to the ETF, but they all do it.
You are absolutely right. The government would face class-action lawsuits filed by some association like EFF on behalf of us.
It is only $14. Personally, I wouldn't waste too much time over it. Just pay it and move on.
I did....but it just don't sit right...Its like Firestone charging a Federal Excise Tax on your tires..then adding it to the total for sales tax...WHAT !!! I told her, hey you cant tax a tax, ohhhhhh I didnt know that..
There he goes again.
Firestone or any particular company doesnt charge or post any taxes they feel like charging.
They're put there by local or federal authorities.
Its not up to the company, they just pass it on to the government.
What part of that dont you understand?
Some companies are mandated by the government to impose these taxes, such as communications. AT&T has no control over this, it is the government.
GAWD......You are thick...First off they dont charge it they collect it.. Excise tax no problem...Sales tax...No problem...YOU CANNOT ADD THE EXCISE TAX TO THE SALES TOTAL THAN CHARGE SALES TAX ON THE ADDED EXCISE TAX...You cannot tax, tax
Tires 10000.00
Mounting fees 35.00
Fed, Excise Tax 100.00
Total 1135.00
Sales Tax 7% 79.45
Total 1214.45
The sales tax should be on the 1035.00...for 72.45..You cannot ad in the excise tax for the total sale...You cannot collect a tax on a collected tax...
Good explanation. I'm not sure why Applejuiced can't comprehend something so simple lol.
Im sure you're not the only one that they collected the particular government fee from. There's many others that paid it and will in the future.
Start a class action suit if you like.
Actually the part that sucks out of all this is the OP having to pay those taxes. I feel you OP since all you want to do is end your contract with no strings attached. I will be ending my current line soon and I will call them to see what I really have to pay.