Agh. I'm a dork. I didn't expect to see actual bands in the store (hadn't checked here first) and was pleased to find sport bands in most colors in Cherry Hill, NJ today. I got all worried about making sure that the box had a SM band (and they have both) that I didn't think at all about that there was a difference between the two watch sizes. I walked away with a 42 and didn't realize until I tried to put it on. What a dork! The moral of the story, be sure to check the size on the band.