Basic MBP 2020 or Mac mini? For basic home computer

[spaceworm]

Looking for a new computer that will primarily be used for distance learning schoolwork (Zoom app, Google Classroom, Youtube, word, safari w/like 10 open tabs; so no heavy gaming or photo/design use). We already have a 27" LG 4k USB-C capable monitor at home so that is plus.

I am considering the following two options:

1.- Refurb Mac Mini i5 8gb 256gb from the apple store ~ $759.00
2.- Basic 2020 13" Macbook Air i3 8gb 256gb from Costco with citi card for extra warranty ~ 950.00

Do you see any performance issues with the MBA connected to an external monitor with this type of use?
I would appreciate your thoughts on which setup do you consider the best choice?

 

[velocityg4]

I'd get the Mac Mini. It has a much faster CPU, roughly twice as fast in multi-tasking/threading. You can also upgrade the RAM when 8GB is no longer sufficient. As I've seen browser tabs using 500MB to 1GB memory each. It's not too far of a stretch that 8GB can be a real hindrance in a couple years. Once you factor in the other apps you have running, OS needs and a few sync services.

 

[Fishrrman]

Unless you have-to-have portability, the Mini is a great choice.

However, I'd suggest 16gb of RAM "from the factory". With 8gb you only get 6.5gb that is actually used by the OS for apps -- because 1.5gb is "roped off" for the graphics.

With 16gb, there's much more "breathing room" for everything.

Be sure to pick a good display for it as well.

 

[Mousse]

One more vote for the Mini. Ergonomics on a laptop is terrible--either the keyboard is too high or the monitor is too low. It's just the nature of the beast.

 

[saudor]

In for mini too. The laptops are only worth considering if you need to move it around alot and take it places.
Technically, the mini could do that to some extent

 

[Jack Neill]

Mac Mini

 

[spaceworm]

It is decided, Mac mini it is 👍. Thanks to everyone