Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

BBC Review

A pretty decent well balanced review, if I were Apple I'd be fairly happy with that.
 
I agree, an honest and intelligent review. IMO this is much more valuable to people than, let's say, some kind of highly biased rose-tinted review from a MacRumors Apple fan ;) Or indeed a biased mud-tinted review from a hater.

The shortcomings are nothing new to Apple, and I'm sure they will be addressed for the iPhone2. (Suddenly a silly idea popped into my head... make a DECT model and call it the iPhoneHome, sell it through BT)
 
ripkord said:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/7079098.stm

He doesnt like it much... it would seem, then again it is the BBC what do they know about gadgetry :)
Click to expand...

They review a lot of gadgets, so they know quite a lot. A minority of people here instantly dismiss a negative ( or portions of ) review of an Apple product with childish responses such as "Apple Haters", "Biased" etc etc.

I agree with the others, its a balanced review - it acknowledges its weaknesses, as well as its strengths. Isn't that what a good review is meant to do?
 
Yep, pretty balanced - basically "good, but maybe not for everyone" which pretty much sums it up for me anyhow.
 
I agree well balanced.

Really we should not be blind to the iPhone's flaws…

The last few lines say it well:
But like the iPod, the iPhone will force every other competitor in the market to raise its game.

And for that consumers should be thankful for the iPhone - even if they have no intention of buying one
Click to expand...
 
It just had a very nice segment on Sky News. Not sure what the guy was on about when he said it doesn't do video though. Perhaps he meant video recording. But overall it was positive. They even had the boss of LG UK in for 15 seconds to say why we should pick up their phone instead. "It does everything the iPhone does and more" - yeah, right.

I'm also getting very tired of people coming out with the old "I guess its alright if you are after a fashion device... but its not that practical" line. Is it the in thing to say these days?
 
All my friends in the UK, make fun of the iPhone. I don't know. This phone is like some politicians. Some people like it, but others hate it . :(
 
as a first pass review ( as opposed to an in depth one ) i think it reads as being very balanced and fair.

to me, still considering whether its worth, i find it pretty fresh to have honest comments along the lines of wifi is great, but the 2G is grindingly slow, but still usable.


I think at this stage, i'm not quite convinced enough yet. :cool:
 
"As a work productivity device the iPhone cannot match Blackberry"

it's not supposed to be a productivity device is it?
ie, you cant do word processing, edit spreadsheets etc..
so why compare?
 
I imported an iphone into Belgium, and everyone I've been showing it to at work is amazed at the way it works so smooth and the way you navigate with it by using your fingertips.

The second thing they are amazed at is how much it costs though :rolleyes:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back