Black Scorpio won't work on a macbook?

[MacBH928]

I was going to buy a black scorpio 500GB SATA II to update my late 2008 macbook(not pro)

but I did a quick research and came up with this thread:
https://discussions.apple.com/message/15041838#15041838

people seem to have an issue installing black scorpio on their MacBooks from that time.

Can any one clear up the situation for me? Is there another brand I should go for? I don't want to pay $100 for a hard drive that will ruin my system

 

[Treeant34]

Re

Morning:

I'm running a Black Scorpio 500Gb in a Macbook 1.1 without issue...

Cheers

 

[saggel]

I have a black scorpio 320 GB too with no problems at all

 

[GodWhomIsMike]

I have that drive with Macbook 7,1 with no issues.

 

[MacBH928]

macbook 1.1 , macbook 7.1
where do u get these numbers? how can i know which is mine?

 

[saggel]

Probably yours is 5.1
Click the apple on the upper left corner and then, about this mac

 

[MacBH928]

Probably yours is 5.1
Click the apple on the upper left corner and then, about this mac

yes yes I do have macbook 5,1, now how can I know I won't face problems with the black scorpio?

 

[saggel]

yes yes I do have macbook 5,1, now how can I know I won't face problems with the black scorpio?

You won't I have been rocking it for more than a year, and it runs smoothly!