Black screen happens to others, too
I have the black screen after waking from sleep on my G4 MDD tower -- no lid, external monitor, etc., to blame. I find it happens about once a month, 2 or 3 times in a row, then it's OK for another month, or so. I feel that if I move the mouse before clicking for wake-up, that it will wake up black, but it doesn't happen all the time. It's annoying that Apple refuses to address this problem.
A workaround I've heard of is to set it to require a password on waking from sleep, but that's more of a bother for me than the occasional black screen.
.