Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

shanshor

macrumors regular
Original poster
Jan 4, 2008
227
82
This iPad has far exceeded all of my expectations. I upgraded from an Air 2 thinking it would mostly be a waste of money, and I expected to return it. I was totally wrong. With iOS 11, this is the most fluid and fun-to-use machine I've ever used. It reminds me of the joy I had with the Palm Pre multitasking gestures back in the day. I thought the Air 2 was a pinnacle of processing power, but even on beta software, the Pro with iOS 11 is an entirely new beast. The pencil writes a little too smoothly for my taste, but other than that, I just came to say that the new Pros are amazing and you should buy one immediately if you've been thinking about it.
 
This iPad has far exceeded all of my expectations. I upgraded from an Air 2 thinking it would mostly be a waste of money, and I expected to return it. I was totally wrong. With iOS 11, this is the most fluid and fun-to-use machine I've ever used. It reminds me of the joy I had with the Palm Pre multitasking gestures back in the day. I thought the Air 2 was a pinnacle of processing power, but even on beta software, the Pro with iOS 11 is an entirely new beast. The pencil writes a little too smoothly for my taste, but other than that, I just came to say that the new Pros are amazing and you should buy one immediately if you've been thinking about it.
Almost the same experience here, upgraded from iPad Pro 9.7 to the 10.5 and could not be happier. I prefer the 'slickness' of the pencil, reminds me of a very fine pen.

Now you have to upgrade your signature, we do not know if you got the 12.9 or the 10.5.
 
Almost the same experience here, upgraded from iPad Pro 9.7 to the 10.5 and could not be happier. I prefer the 'slickness' of the pencil, reminds me of a very fine pen.

Now you have to upgrade your signature, we do not know if you got the 12.9 or the 10.5.

Did the same upgrade. Yes, it's an impressive device. What I have been waiting for all this time. The difference in the experience between the 9.7 and 10.5 is much more than you would expect just based on the specs.
 
Is the new 10.5 iPad as light as the air 2 on your hands? I prefer to use my air 2 over my 1st gen 12,9 pro because of this and I begin to think of an upgrade for the pro 10.5 over my air 2 but its important to know before if the weight of the device feels the same as an air 2.

Thanks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gobikerider
I saw the 10.5" at Best Buy and touched the screen a few times. Believe it or not, that was enough to convince me that it was a worthy upgrade from my Air 2. And I really loved the Air 2!

The 120 HZ Promotion display makes a significant difference with the overall responsiveness of the Dislay. Defintely a selling point in comparison to older iPad models.
 
Is the new 10.5 iPad as light as the air 2 on your hands? I prefer to use my air 2 over my 1st gen 12,9 pro because of this and I begin to think of an upgrade for the pro 10.5 over my air 2 but its important to know before if the weight of the device feels the same as an air 2.

Thanks.
I don't notice any difference, honestly. The overall footprint is almost the same. Not nearly as drastically larger as the 12.9" model.
 
Yup, great device. IMO it’s definitely a larger upgrade than the iPad 2 to the Air was, well except for the screen upgrade as I literally said holy sh## when I got it as I haven’t seen a retina iPad until I got the Air. The fluidness of it is unmatched because of the 120hz combined with the speed is very satisfying. 4 GB of ram helps a lot too.
 
I'm still working away on my iPad Mini 3... Wondering if I should hold out for another year and hope for a iPhone X like design on the next iPad Pro.
 
xAnthony – a fine idea; they totally do make big-splashing products the later inspirators of their commonplace traits, don't they?

Meanwhile, upgrading from the mini 3 to anything is substantial; I eventually sold my mini 3 after not feeling a particular need for it, and will never let go of my mini 4.
 
Not a awful idea tbh, the 12.9 is due for a design refresh tbh. OMg the edge to edge screen on iPads will be insane.
Edge to edge will be impossible to hold with two hands, let alone with one!!
Don’t get me wrong, I like the idea of the iPhone 8/X/Edition/whatever but holding an iPhone is a little bit different from holding an 12.9 screen!
 
Yah
Edge to edge will be impossible to hold with two hands, let alone with one!!
Don’t get me wrong, I like the idea of the iPhone 8/X/Edition/whatever but holding an iPhone is a little bit different from holding an 12.9 screen!
your right I'm not sure if it would work on a iPad. The border acts as structural support
 
This iPad has far exceeded all of my expectations. I upgraded from an Air 2 thinking it would mostly be a waste of money, and I expected to return it. I was totally wrong. With iOS 11, this is the most fluid and fun-to-use machine I've ever used. It reminds me of the joy I had with the Palm Pre multitasking gestures back in the day. I thought the Air 2 was a pinnacle of processing power, but even on beta software, the Pro with iOS 11 is an entirely new beast. The pencil writes a little too smoothly for my taste, but other than that, I just came to say that the new Pros are amazing and you should buy one immediately if you've been thinking about it.

That's awesome, which Pro did you go for?
 
I'm super impressed with the IPP 10.5 as well after upgrading from the IPP 9.7.
The sound that the speakers alone generate is great and makes media use so much more enjoyable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jetcat3
The only problem with the current iPad design is that damn chamfered edge. It's so prone to nicks and dings, you have to treat it like a Faberge Egg. Would have preferred a redesign with the iPhone rounded edges.
 
Wish I hadn't read this thread. Been thinking about selling (giving to the wife) my Air 2 and getting a 10.5 pro.
And this has just probably pushed me over the edge.
Also mean my MacBook will getting even less use.
 
The only problem with the current iPad design is that damn chamfered edge. It's so prone to nicks and dings, you have to treat it like a Faberge Egg. Would have preferred a redesign with the iPhone rounded edges.
Not something that bothers me, but I do agree with your statement. I don't have any issues with the chamfered edges getting banged up on my iPads, but I do wish they'd do it like they did with the iPhone SE and start bead blasting those shiny edges along with the rest of the iPad. It would just look nicer.
 
Not something that bothers me, but I do agree with your statement. I don't have any issues with the chamfered edges getting banged up on my iPads, but I do wish they'd do it like they did with the iPhone SE and start bead blasting those shiny edges along with the rest of the iPad. It would just look nicer.
Funnily enough, the entry level 2017 iPad 9.7 does have bead blasted chamfered edges. Reckon that's a cheaper finish but I wish Apple had done the same with the iPad Pros. It really is far more practical. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: spiderman0616
The Apple Silicone case didn’t have the ding/nick problem. But for the 10.5 there isn’t such a thing and when I bought it there weren’t any decent 3th party cases.

So I started using the 12.9 and 10.5 both naked with their ASK and loved it. It’s a really nice feeling to have an iPad without case, thin, light, smooth but (just) not slippery.
The 12.9 now has an ever so slight scratch on the bag. Something like a grain of sand that scratched it and it annoys me to no end. But I’ve decided to get over it and use the hell out of both iPads.

My only (OCD) hope is that they will go the way of a bridle leather bag: it’s so nice and pristine when it comes out of the dust bag. But oh dear, oh dear, the first scratch goes right trough your soul.

Yet after a few years of careful daily use and good care (slow drying when wet, a bimonthly coat of cream) it really gets patina and looks the world. Problem is that a top quality leather bag can last for decades yet an work ipad only lasts for a two years. Possibly these Pro’s can last three years but certainly not longer then four.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Wormald
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.