bluetooth headphone + speaker possible?

cjlizzard

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Nov 16, 2018
5
0
Hello; I am hard of hearing and added some bluetooth headphones to by ATV but it appears that the sound exclusively goes either to the headphones or to the stereo speakers. Is there a way for my family to listen over the speakers while i listen via the headphones?
 

HDFan

macrumors 68020
Jun 30, 2007
2,106
525
So your connection path is bluetooth headphones > Apple TV > ? what device(s) ? Where are the speakers, TV in this path?
 
Comment

cjlizzard

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Nov 16, 2018
5
0
So your connection path is bluetooth headphones > Apple TV > ? what device(s) ? Where are the speakers, TV in this path?
ATV>Bluetooth
ATV>TV>Stereo
i am listening to the bluetooth headphones thru the ATV. Signal from the ATV goes to the TV and then audio out to the stereo amp.
I dont see a way around this. As soon as I turn on bluetooth thru the ATV or the TV the signal goes exclusively to the bluetooth device. I was thinking there might be a way to split the signal at the amp but I am not sure there is such a product and if there was it would likely go into the headphone jack with would again eliminate the speakers.
 
Comment

570934

Suspended
May 3, 2011
710
107
Hello; I am hard of hearing and added some bluetooth headphones to by ATV but it appears that the sound exclusively goes either to the headphones or to the stereo speakers. Is there a way for my family to listen over the speakers while i listen via the headphones?
I've been looking at solutions on and off over the years cjlizzard. You can get splitters and bluetooth units but there'a a major problem once you get both signals working as you want, and that is lag. The BT headphone are always going to be quite chunk of time behind the wired signal so it get's pretty old pretty quickly.

So the options are for wired setups only so a TV which can output both Tv speakers and headphones together.
 
Comment

waw74

macrumors 68040
May 27, 2008
3,336
268
you could add an HDMI audio extractor, and a bluetooth transmitter

the extractor would go in the HDMI line between your aTV and the TV.
the bluetooth transmitter would then send the audio to the headphones.

as an example
from a quick amazon search, do your research before purchasing
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00KBHX072/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_ep_dp_Y9y8BbZEN35Y9 - hmdi extractor.
https://www.amazon.com/HomeSpot-Bluetooth-Transmitter-Headphones-Simultaneously/dp/B00QV77YIC - bluetooth transmitter.

this extractor mentions that it passes the full sound to the HDMI out port.

you may have to set the aTV to only output stereo
 
  • Like
Reactions: M1ckab
Comment

cjlizzard

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Nov 16, 2018
5
0
you could add an HDMI audio extractor, and a bluetooth transmitter

the extractor would go in the HDMI line between your aTV and the TV.
the bluetooth transmitter would then send the audio to the headphones.

as an example
from a quick amazon search, do your research before purchasing
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00KBHX072/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_ep_dp_Y9y8BbZEN35Y9 - hmdi extractor.
https://www.amazon.com/HomeSpot-Bluetooth-Transmitter-Headphones-Simultaneously/dp/B00QV77YIC - bluetooth transmitter.

this extractor mentions that it passes the full sound to the HDMI out port.

you may have to set the aTV to only output stereo
[doublepost=1542560276][/doublepost]Awesome, thank you and I will check it out. Some of the new hearing aids pass Bluetooth signal directly to the aid via a dongle I think. Apparently there is no delay and other listeners can listen to the speakers, so there is a way to do it!
 
Comment

cjlizzard

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Nov 16, 2018
5
0
[doublepost=1542560276][/doublepost]Awesome, thank you and I will check it out. Some of the new hearing aids pass Bluetooth signal directly to the aid via a dongle I think. Apparently there is no delay and other listeners can listen to the speakers, so there is a way to do it!
Waw74....still a little confused on where the Bluetooth transmitter sits in the system? What’s the point of the HDMI transmitter if it just passing signal to the tv? Or is the transmitter connected to that? I’m confused!?!
 
Comment

waw74

macrumors 68040
May 27, 2008
3,336
268
sorry just saw this

the HDMI box is used to split the audio out of the HDMI signal
the other box is used to transmit that audio to your headphones.

so... (devices are red, cable is black)

aTV
|
|
<HDMI cable>
|
|
extractor ---<optical/analog>--- Transmitter ===<bluetooth>=== headphones
|
|
<HDMI cable>
|
|
Television

---------
For the optical/analog cable, you can use either a tos-link cable, or an analog cable that has the standard headphone jack on one end and red/white RCA plugs on the other end. and looking back, both of those are included with the transmitter.


You will have to make sure you set the aTV to stereo output, as the transmitter can't handle surround sound.
 
Comment

cjlizzard

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Nov 16, 2018
5
0
sorry just saw this

the HDMI box is used to split the audio out of the HDMI signal
the other box is used to transmit that audio to your headphones.

so... (devices are red, cable is black)

aTV
|
|
<HDMI cable>
|
|
extractor ---<optical/analog>--- Transmitter ===<bluetooth>=== headphones
|
|
<HDMI cable>
|
|
Television

---------
For the optical/analog cable, you can use either a tos-link cable, or an analog cable that has the standard headphone jack on one end and red/white RCA plugs on the other end. and looking back, both of those are included with the transmitter.


You will have to make sure you set the aTV to stereo output, as the transmitter can't handle surround sound.
Ok thanks that makes sense

Would you expect any delay between the headphones and the speakers, which would result in an echo effect
 
Comment

priitv8

macrumors 68040
Jan 13, 2011
3,618
465
Estonia
Would you expect any delay between the headphones and the speakers, which would result in an echo effect
The digital processing times (ie delays) are always there and unpredictable in the digital world.
Would a wired analog headphone be an option for you? That one at least has zero latency.
 
Comment

570934

Suspended
May 3, 2011
710
107
Ok thanks that makes sense

Would you expect any delay between the headphones and the speakers, which would result in an echo effect
As I said in my previous post the delay makes it very very hard work to watch TV with both BT headphones and the TV speaker on at the same time. I’ve been playing with various setups over the years.
However, what I am hopefully for is Airplay2 headphones, if like me you can play to multiple Airplay systems the delay ‘maybe’ similar so maybe manageable. There are a couple of headphones due soon using Airplay2 so I may have to give one a go.
The only solution currently is to use a splitter nd hardwire the headphone rather than Bluetooth them. This is how I watch quite a lot of tv along with my wife. Luckily our newer Tv offers both tv speakers and wired headphones simultaneously, but my wife can’t enjoy the Sonos system when we do.
 
Comment

priitv8

macrumors 68040
Jan 13, 2011
3,618
465
Estonia
However, what I am hopefully for is Airplay2 headphones, if like me you can play to multiple Airplay systems the delay ‘maybe’ similar so maybe manageable.
My impression about AirPlay is, that it somehow manages to sync the delays over different paths. This is a really strong selling point of AirPlay.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 570934
Comment

570934

Suspended
May 3, 2011
710
107
I’m still surprised that no big name manufacturer hasn’t release a AP2 headphone set as of yet mainly due to the uncompressed audio compared to BNT audio.
 
Comment

priitv8

macrumors 68040
Jan 13, 2011
3,618
465
Estonia
I’m still surprised that no big name manufacturer hasn’t release a AP2 headphone set as of yet mainly due to the uncompressed audio compared to BNT audio.
As of today, the only way to have an AP2 headphone, would be to use latest AirPort Express (received AP2 firmware update in August), and wired headphones.
Just tried this out of curiosity, and the amp has enough power to drive my Sony MDR-CD770 headphones.

So, this could be a solution for OP, to get synced audio from AVR main speakers and AP2 connected headphones.
 
Last edited:
Comment
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.