Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Bought the 15" rMBP a while ago. Regrets?

D

drewjonn

macrumors regular
Original poster
Feb 15, 2016
139
30
From what I've heard, this would be the first time they do a re-design to MBP and MBA after few generations, and if they would look thinner and offer more colors like the 12" rMB, then this would be a huge regret for me. and this rMBP I just bought around 5 months ago would just be the last of the design so far. I'd argue that this might be the biggest upgrade they've ever done to the MBP line.

Should I sell it and spend more for the new model?
 
snaky69 said:
I think you're placing aesthetics over function. A computer's a tool.

Unless it doesn't do what you need it to do, I don't see a reason to upgrade.
Click to expand...

Spec upgrades such as Skylake are also coming with it. Well, everybody is different, and I might have got myself the Dell XPS15 or any ugly Windows notebook if it's solely about the function.

I mean, most people pay more for Macs because look is a major consideration, right?
 
kindaHipster said:
Spec upgrades such as Skylake are also coming with it. Well, everybody is different, and I might have got myself the Dell XPS15 or any ugly Windows notebook if it's solely about the function.

I mean, most people pay more for Macs because look is a major consideration, right?
Click to expand...

That's correct.
 
Honestly, it really depends on your needs. Are you anticipating a need to use USB type C or Thunderbolt 3 immediately? Can you live with buying adapters for your old USB ports if that's the case? Does the OLED bar seem intriguing, not gimmicky to you? If so, then maybe it's worth it. But honestly, the model you have is a solid machine. I've had mine for 7 months now. Best tech decision I ever made. Only real complaint I have is that the AMD GPU gets pretty hot under load. So really it's up to you. The 2015 is a guaranteed great machine. The 2016 will probably awesome too.
 
ceparker27 said:
Honestly, it really depends on your needs. Are you anticipating a need to use USB type C or Thunderbolt 3 immediately? Can you live with buying adapters for your old USB ports if that's the case? Does the OLED bar seem intriguing, not gimmicky to you? If so, then maybe it's worth it. But honestly, the model you have is a solid machine. I've had mine for 7 months now. Best tech decision I ever made. Only real complaint I have is that the AMD GPU gets pretty hot under load. So really it's up to you. The 2015 is a guaranteed great machine. The 2016 will probably awesome too.
Click to expand...

...until the dGPU fails.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sully
I bought the same model as you recently with the intention of exchanging it with the "new and improved" version if it happens.

So far I haven't heard anything that is appealing for me and the more I have used my 2015, the more I like it.

So like others have said, it is strictly a personal decision.

tubeexperience said:
...until the dGPU fails.
Click to expand...
Hi, could you please explain this. Is there a history of the dGPU failing in the the 2015 rMBA ?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
charlyee said:
Hi, could you please explain this. Is there a history of the dGPU failing in the the 2015 rMBA ?
Click to expand...

We will all find out in 2-3 years, equally Apple`s track record with MBP & dGPU is tragic at best. Just search the forum, it`s pretty evident, here`s a good place as any https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/dgpu-or-not.1974487/

Personally I won't but another portable Mac with dGPU as Apple places far to much emphasis on form over function, nor does this failure mechanism raise it`s head early the systems life. Add in how Apple deals with mass failure of their product. I just don't need the hassle on an allegedly premium product.

Q-6
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: lympero, charlyee and Sully
The alleged 2016 model doesn't appeal to me. I don't want to be forced to use a pile of adapters for accessories I need, and the OLED bar strikes me as a stupid gimmick. Not only that, but the sky lake boost will be fairly minimal, and any energy gain will be negated by the ever-driving need for Apple to make things thinner.

tubeexperience said:
...until the dGPU fails.
Click to expand...
You've literally mentioned something about that in every thread I've seen you post in on the MBP forum. Get over it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sparkie1984 and charlyee
tubeexperience said:
There has long been a history of the dGPU failing in almost every model year of the MacBook Pro.
Click to expand...

Listen to this.

Don't bother with the gpu option. Just get the base 15" and put the money left over (US $500) to make a windows desktop. Win Win.

Unless you really really really need the GPU option in the 15" to travel with you everywhere.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tubeexperience
kindaHipster said:
Should I sell it and spend more for the new model?
Click to expand...
If you want a different color Mac, such as rose gold, then yes. Sell the Mac and get one that suits your tastes.

Wait until tomorrow and see what (if anything) apple does with the MBP. Rumors have been all over the map with the MBP, so its hard to say what will happen. The 2015 model is a great computer, and i'm sure its fast enough for you needs, so much so, its probably doubtful that the 2016 model will present such a boost in performance that you need to buy that. My 2012 rMBP is fast enough to run lightroom, photoshop and a bunch of other apps, never mind a 2015 model.

Aesthetics do go a long way, but I also agree with the others, that in the end the laptop is a tool, but if you care about the looks and like what apple does at WWDC, then the choice is easy, sell what you have and upgrade.
 
  • Like
Reactions: j1104638
kindaHipster said:
From what I've heard, this would be the first time they do a re-design to MBP and MBA after few generations, and if they would look thinner and offer more colors like the 12" rMB, then this would be a huge regret for me. and this rMBP I just bought around 5 months ago would just be the last of the design so far. I'd argue that this might be the biggest upgrade they've ever done to the MBP line.

Should I sell it and spend more for the new model?
Click to expand...

Check your bank account, you'll find the answer there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Samuelsan2001 and tubeexperience
kindaHipster said:
I mean, most people pay more for Macs because look is a major consideration, right?
Click to expand...

Not me. I have need a system to run well and make it easier for me to do my work. Looks don't really matter.

If looks did matter I would pick a windows systems. The MS Surface Pro and Surface Book, HP Spectre, Dell XPS ,... are sexier looking than any MBP.
 
jerryk said:
Not me. I have need a system to run well and make it easier for me to do my work. Looks don't really matter.

If looks did matter I would pick a windows systems. The MS Surface Pro and Surface Book, HP Spectre, Dell XPS ,... are sexier looking than any MBP.
Click to expand...

Can't disagree more but hey after all I mentioned it was all about preferences. I love the Mac OSX but in my opinion all Apple products are simply the only cool gadgets to carry to coffee shops or school.

Regardless, I believe that the Windows honestly offers better specs, especially for smooth gaming (luckily I don't game)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back