Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I'd prefer no store, and just download/install apps directly. I don't need nor want a middleman, Apple, the carriers, or otherwise.

I don't even care if the App Store is default. Just me let take an .ipa and do with it as I wish.

...then, maybe, I can get Firefox with plugin support.
Sure, but those days never existed, so in that case, it may be something to dream of or pine for, but not something to miss.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: gco212 and TheHeron
It’s fine if you just don’t like Apple & their business model. But trying to claim Apple is being “anticompetitive” with a 9.1% marketshare is just silly. If you want to have a serious conversation, fine. But don’t insult our intelligence.
 
Consumers have a choice of mobile device to purchase.

But they have little to no choice of mobile application store to sign up with and download/buy apps from.

Nor (getting back to topic here) choice of digital payment system on phones.
They DO have a choice, one choice that lets them sign up and download from pretty much anywhere. The ONLY place it can’t download/buy apps from is the Apple App Store. So, for someone who has a primary requirement that “My device must allow me to install what I want however I want to install it”, if they’re NOT buying a non-Apple device, then they’re not listening to their own requirements!
 
👉 And so far - more precisely: given Apple's behaviour and obstinate noncompliance - it's looking quite good that the EU will eventually impose period penalties on them. 😎
Nah, the current regulators aren’t trying to vy for some higher political office like Vestager was. Even before taking office, it was clear that they felt their priorities lay elsewhere. They were locked in discussions with Apple (something Vestager never allowed) in order for Apple to produce a document they broadly agree with. It’s not perfect and folks that were expecting something like Vestager’s grandstanding ultimatums will be disappointed. But, those regulators have other things they want to accomplish, so getting this behind them is just their first job.
 
They sure did; remember Palm and Windows CE mobile devices? You bought apps from anywhere you like
PDA’s rather than smartphones, yah, you’re right, those had some degree of popularity. If they were better at being what people wanted to buy, they might even still be around today.

And I guess that’s the point, really. What a good number of people seem to want to spend money on is something quite different from what the majority of people are willing to spend money on. To the point where if something a particular user specifically wants isn’t available for them to buy, one major reason why is that there’s not enough other people that want the same thing such that someone could build, market, and sell it and make a profit doing so.

There may have been hundreds of thousands that relished buying apps from anywhere, but millions upon millions that preferred just having whatever they want to buy in one main location.
 
Last edited:
What happens if Apple refuses to pay the fine? Brazil bans Apple products? That seems like a win for Apple. A loss for Brazilians. Maybe it is time Apple said “Up Yours” to these countries. Who are doing nothing but seeking money for nothing.
 
Stronger than that, they're making a case for why Apple makes for a lousy nanny.

The theoretical benefits aren't here, but the issues are very real.
Not theoretical, proven. Case study in the opposite is the Google Play Store littered with junk.

 
I agree with open NFC access, but not open App Store access and side loading.

close the app store all you want, who really cares. having an issue with "side loading" is looking at a user and saying "you shouldn't be able to install what you want."

sideloading is some weird new-agey term for "use an operating system as it has always been designed to function, by installing things you choose to install."

i absolutely despise when macOS actively prevents me from installing something because it doesnt come from the app store, and it wasn't signed in some way that makes apple happy. and then i have to go through security settings to "approve" this action, and then i'm still asked if i want to go through with it, courtesy of ridiculous warnings.

otherwise, go to windows and double click an exe. life is happy, and i havent seen a virus in at least 15 years. something about being a user who is capable of understanding safe material makes my device interactions perfectly fine.

even when i was jailbreaking iphones i never had an issue. this whole "no sideloading" thing is idiotic, and it's amazing how easily impressionable americans are that apple can convince customers it's a bad thing. too bad our gov't doesnt have the same spine and general care of the population that the EU has for theirs.
 
close the app store all you want, who really cares. having an issue with "side loading" is looking at a user and saying "you shouldn't be able to install what you want."

sideloading is some weird new-agey term for "use an operating system as it has always been designed to function, by installing things you choose to install."

It's weird that the term "sideloading" doesn't appear anywhere on this "Install and uninstall apps from the internet or a disc on Mac" Apple support page


"Sideloading" = "Installing Apps"
 
close the app store all you want, who really cares. having an issue with "side loading" is looking at a user and saying "you shouldn't be able to install what you want."

sideloading is some weird new-agey term for "use an operating system as it has always been designed to function, by installing things you choose to install."

i absolutely despise when macOS actively prevents me from installing something because it doesnt come from the app store, and it wasn't signed in some way that makes apple happy. and then i have to go through security settings to "approve" this action, and then i'm still asked if i want to go through with it, courtesy of ridiculous warnings.

otherwise, go to windows and double click an exe. life is happy, and i havent seen a virus in at least 15 years. something about being a user who is capable of understanding safe material makes my device interactions perfectly fine.

even when i was jailbreaking iphones i never had an issue. this whole "no sideloading" thing is idiotic, and it's amazing how easily impressionable americans are that apple can convince customers it's a bad thing. too bad our gov't doesnt have the same spine and general care of the population that the EU has for theirs.
you may be tech savvy but the population as a whole is not. I'd much rather hop through a few pop-ups knowing the software has been vetted than having to waste time deep diving into the code of everything I download.

And if it's opened up, you'll have a bunch of 'anti-virus' companies peddling their bloatware doing poorly what Apple already does well, which is mitigating malware spread.
 
What happens if Apple refuses to pay the fine? Brazil bans Apple products? That seems like a win for Apple. A loss for Brazilians. Maybe it is time Apple said “Up Yours” to these countries. Who are doing nothing but seeking money for nothing.
It depends on how much the fine is. I’d be willing to bet that, like the EU, they will make the fine smallish because what they want more than anything else is to keep those App Store dollars coming in. They just want a reason to take some money off the top and they just provided themselves with that reason.

If you want to examine the actions of regions that want change more than money (heh), look at China and Indonesia. Both willing to prevent the sale of hardware in the region until Apple met their demands. Guess what? Apple met those demands.
 
would love to go back to the previous version.
as far I remember, this is actually possible.
now the real question is whether that old version will work on a newer OS in the future.
the sad truth is that the dev can change the backend anytime and this would render all prior versions unusable. I suspect there are only a few exceptions where the game doesn't demand network connectivity...
 
They DO have a choice, one choice that lets them sign up and download from pretty much anywhere
No. Virtually all Android apps are distributed through Google's Play Store. Very few can not be downloaded from that. Not too mention the reliance on Play services.

I'm forced to use Google Play on iOS almost as much as I have to use Apple's App Store on iOS.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ToothBlueth
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.