Broadwell vs. Haswell Air: worth waiting for?

smileman

macrumors regular
Original poster
Oct 23, 2011
125
19
Supposedly Broadwell will allow laptops like the Air to do away with fans entirely, which sounds incredible in terms of space savings, eliminating noise, battery savings, etc.

http://www.engadget.com/2013/06/06/hp-fanless-intel-haswell-tablet/

I'm guessing if the Broadwell Air can do away with a fan entirely then that is when we'll see the next design refresh.

So with Broadwell due out in a year's time would it be worth waiting for it?
 
Last edited:

thekev

macrumors 604
Aug 5, 2010
6,715
1,782
I can't find what is used in that reference spec, but intel makes a lot of claims when projecting far out.
 

QCassidy352

macrumors G4
Mar 20, 2003
10,618
2,740
Bay Area
do away with fans entirely?? wow, that sounds terrific. But, I won't be waiting.

There will always be something terrific right around the corner, theoretically. Often doesn't really work out that way. And if it turns out to really be that good, I could always sell my Haswell MBA and upgrade for a relatively modest cost.
 

old-wiz

macrumors G3
Mar 26, 2008
8,320
221
West Suburban Boston Ma
But by the time Broadwell comes out people will be saying that the next generation (farwell?) will have ??? and you should definitely wait for that.

You can wind up buying nothing if you keep postponing just to have 1 more feature.
 

Stetrain

macrumors 68040
Feb 6, 2009
3,548
17
Or buy now, use it for a year, and sell it for whatever you can. A couple hundred dollars of depreciation isn't a bad price for having a nice laptop for a year.
 

mortenandersen

macrumors 6502
Apr 9, 2011
401
16
Norway
OPs point posted earlier...

smileman wrote 9 June:
"Broadwell vs. Haswell Air: worth waiting for?
Supposedly Broadwell will allow laptops like the Air to do away with fans entirely, which sounds incredible in terms of space savings, eliminating noise, battery savings, etc.

http://www.engadget.com/2013/06/06/h...aswell-tablet/

I'm guessing if the Broadwell Air can do away with a fan entirely then that is when we'll see the next design refresh.

So with Broadwell due out in a year's time would it be worth waiting for it?
Last edited by smileman; Today at 00:57."


I wrote 8 June:

"Fanless Broadwell, and possible even Haswell?
Quote:
Originally Posted by skaertus View Post
I've seen nothing yet on heat dissipation on Broadwell. Where did you read the article?"

I answered 8 June:

"Engadget wrote this a few days ago:

http://www.engadget.com/2013/06/06/h...aswell-tablet/

It reads: "[...] We thought we wouldn't get to see a fanless Intel Core portable until Haswell's successor, Broadwell (and its even smaller 14nm chips) started doing the rounds in a few years [...]". (According to the roadmap Broadwell will be launched next summer, if my memory is correct.)""

But I didn't think that this info deserved a thread of its own. "smileman" obviously did think so.
 
Last edited:

DisplacedMic

macrumors 65816
May 1, 2009
1,411
1
Supposedly Broadwell will allow laptops like the Air to do away with fans entirely, which sounds incredible in terms of space savings, eliminating noise, battery savings, etc.

http://www.engadget.com/2013/06/06/hp-fanless-intel-haswell-tablet/

I'm guessing if the Broadwell Air can do away with a fan entirely then that is when we'll see the next design refresh.

So with Broadwell due out in a year's time would it be worth waiting for it?
well...considering the conference starts tomorrow....yeah - i would say it's at least worth waiting to see what's what.
 

Mrbobb

macrumors 601
Aug 27, 2012
4,989
192
Fanless? I wish. Not gonna happen for the following reasons:

Is in the folklore of Apple's history that when the first Mac was created, Jobs insisted NO FAN! So no need to tell Apple fan ain't cool, they know.

Fast forward to the iMac Cube, again Jobs insisted no fan and the Cube was plagued by heat problem.

Despite ever more efficient chips, Haswell, Broadwell, Faswell ^) whatever, Apple will always be pressured to keep the performance up to keep the competitors at bay and for the majority of customers who purchase by the numbers. We silent lovers are in the minority.

Performance = heat.
 

skaertus

macrumors 68040
Feb 23, 2009
3,328
449
Brazil
Is it worth waiting to see? Broadwell is at least one year away from us. And Intel may choose to delay it, as it has done with every processor since Sandy Bridge. Intel may find out that sales of Haswell are lagging, or may find another glitch in the product that delays it. Who knows? I've already waited forever for the release of Haswell, I'm not playing this game again.
 

xVeinx

macrumors 6502
Oct 9, 2006
361
0
California
Current leaked roadmaps are indicating a Haswell refresh in 2014, with Broadwell not arriving until 2015. The push to 14 nm is going to take time. Between leaks and everything else, Haswell started off as a "game changer" and over a years time became "improved graphics and some better power consumption numbers", with the real game-changing performance and power reductions coming with Broadwell. Until real people run real code, the numbers might as well be made up. Broadwell may be great, especially after a 2 year incubation time, or it may not be a awe-inspiring as we hope. We won't know until it makes it into the hands of reviewers (and preferably the "common man").
 

calvol

macrumors 6502a
Feb 3, 2011
991
2
I'm waiting:
- DDR4 memory
- IGZO display
- redesigned shell
- 14 nm process

That will be a huge jump in battery life.
 

Steve121178

macrumors 603
Apr 13, 2010
5,032
4,102
Bedfordshire, UK
So with Broadwell due out in a year's time would it be worth waiting for it?
The next generation is always going to be better than the current.

You can keep waiting to infinity if you follow this way of thinking as there's always going to be something better just over the horizon.

----------

I'm waiting:
- DDR4 memory
- IGZO display
- redesigned shell
- 14 nm process

That will be a huge jump in battery life.
To be honest the huge jump will be when we move away from the 1970's battery tech that we still use in today's products.
 

dusk007

macrumors 68040
Dec 5, 2009
3,386
61
Fanless will only be true for the Y series Broadwells. Like the Y series Haswells are almost cool enough to go fanless. One can probably do it already but usually you'd need extra weight to pull of some decent passive cooling. On a tablet it is easy just make the underside a cooling block with some rifled design to increase surface area.

You won't see a MBA fanless because that would be a huge downgrade. Broadwell is just 14nm but otherwise will mostly be quite similar to Haswell. There are some efficiency gains but nothing that will get the performance of a 15W CPU down to <8 for passive cooling.
 

PeteJames

macrumors regular
Sep 11, 2010
133
0
England
Are there any good sources for finding out what performance increases / other benefits Broadwell and Skylake may bring? When are they supposed to be going mainstream? Could do with a good simple source for chip news.

I'd love a silent laptop more than almost anything. That's the dream.
 

skaertus

macrumors 68040
Feb 23, 2009
3,328
449
Brazil
Are there any good sources for finding out what performance increases / other benefits Broadwell and Skylake may bring? When are they supposed to be going mainstream? Could do with a good simple source for chip news.

I'd love a silent laptop more than almost anything. That's the dream.
Broadwell is a die shrink of Haswell, from 22 to 14nm. Skylane is a whole new architecture, with the 14nm process. I expect performance to be very slightly increased from Haswell to Broadwell, as well as better thermal management thanks to the new process. As for Skylane, I don't really know what to expect.
 

r6mile

macrumors 6502
Feb 3, 2010
437
92
London, UK
I'm all for waiting, if it's 2-3 months. But when something has literally JUST been released, that you want to wait for the NEXT release, frankly seems silly.
There's always going to be better technology around the corner.
 

Livewings

macrumors regular
Dec 16, 2012
196
3
Supposedly Broadwell will allow laptops like the Air to do away with fans entirely, which sounds incredible in terms of space savings, eliminating noise, battery savings, etc.

http://www.engadget.com/2013/06/06/hp-fanless-intel-haswell-tablet/

I'm guessing if the Broadwell Air can do away with a fan entirely then that is when we'll see the next design refresh.

So with Broadwell due out in a year's time would it be worth waiting for it?
I think you should wait for Skylake. It will be better than Broadwell. Oh wait, Skymont seems better than Skylake too. I think you should just wait for 10nm Skymont MBAs. It would be worth the wait. Just 3 years to go. :rolleyes:
 

paulrbeers

macrumors 68040
Dec 17, 2009
3,960
120
I'm definitely waiting for Broadwell now, looks like Haswell runs HOT!

http://www.bit-tech.net/news/hardware/2013/06/06/haswell-heat/1

Even hotter than Ivy, which was hotter than SB!
Good luck then! Looks like Broadwell just got pushed back to 2015....

http://www.dailytech.com/Report+Intel+Delays+14+nm+Broadwell+Schedules+Haswell+Refresh+for+2014/article31770.htm

To all who worry about temps, while transferring files from my Sandy Bridge i5 2011 Macbook Air, to my new 2013 i7 MBA: The 2013 was dead silent while the 2011 fans were spinning up. Both sitting next to each other, both doing the same "work"....

Just sayin!
 

scaredpoet

macrumors 604
Apr 6, 2007
6,627
342
I'm definitely waiting for Broadwell now, looks like Haswell runs HOT!
It runs hot if you overclock it, which Apple does not do. The crux of that article was that system builders who are configuring systems that deliberately overclock the non-mobile Haswell CPUs, are bellyaching because the top overclock speed of production Haswell chips is lower than than preproduction samples, before they start to melt down.

Chip manufacturers don't, and never have, guarantee performance at speeds beyond what they've rated.

I any case, everyone so far with a 2013 MBA has said it doesn't run hot at all. Mine's arriving tomorrow, so I'll probably run some h.264 video transcodes (which I normally do on an iMac) and take my non-contact thermometer to it and see what happens.
 
Last edited:

Zammir

macrumors newbie
Sep 10, 2012
9
1
Las Vegas
It runs hot if you overclock it, which Apple does not do. The crux of that article was that system builders who are configuring systems that deliberately overclock the non-mobile Haswell CPUs, are bellyaching because the top overclock speed of production Haswell chips is lower than than preproduction samples, before they start to melt down.

Chip manufacturers don't, and never have, guarantee performance at speeds beyond what they've rated.

I any case, everyone so far with a 2013 MBA has said it doesn't run hot at all. Mine's arriving tomorrow, so I'll probably run some h.264 video transcodes (which I normally do on an iMac) and take my non-contact thermometer to it and see what happens.
Any update on your findings?
 

Ifti

macrumors 68020
Dec 14, 2010
2,264
431
UK
Im currently waiting for a Haswell rMBP because its literally round the corner.
I wouldnt wait a full year for an update. Seriously just buy the machine and enjoy it. Every year something better will come along, thats just the nature of technology. You can wait a year, and you'll hear rumours of the developments for the following year, which will be much better etc. Its a continuous cycle. Where will you stop?