Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
What I don’t like about those accessories is that they don’t offer a 360 degrees protection of the edges, none of them neither the Magic Keyboard nor the Logitech nor this one. I don’t get that. The Logitech Combo Touch could easily have added a slim TPU layer or something where the pen charges, like other cases. The charging mechanism would still work. I now already have a scratch on that side which is the reason why I returned the Combo Touch. And the Magic Keyboard is even worse concerning edge protection.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fc4090
Logitech uses it, but other than that - yeah, it’s strange. Not sure why.
Cost. Must be quite costly and I doubt unless you have larger economies of scale it is worth it. Whereas Bluetooth is widely available and much cheaper to use.



 
?Sigh, after only having the 12.9" Max+ for a couple a days, the critical comments are making me strongly consider putting it back in the box for a return/refund. I'll give it until Monday and decide.

I can probably live with the weight, but the reliability issues, and durability issues (as reported by others in this thread) are concerning as it isn't a cheap product.

Is there anyone out there with long term experience that is happy with this device? I know when one is content with a product it isn't as tempting to speak out as when you are not.
They were pretty chill about refunding. I think I had mine about 45 days when refunding. It lasted about 35-40 days before it broke. I hadn’t even left the house with it yet or done any sort of travel. Just sitting on the couch or at the kitchen table, and about half the time I wasn’t even using it and had the simple Apple folio on which is better for casual use and drawing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jazz1
I want to love the Magic Keyboard with my 12.9, but I would give it maybe 5/10. My issues:

1) Top heaviness. When it's on my lap and the chair is not super low, the keyboard bounces as I type. I find it really unstable/uncomfortable for lap usage.
2) Weight/thickness. It's thicker and heavier than a MacBook Air, about the same as MacBook Pro. Suddenly my tablet is not so portable.
3) Battery. My 2018 iPad Pro really takes a battery hit with the keyboard. Only get 2-3 hours max when using the keyboard, again negating the battery advantage the iPad used to have over laptops.
4) Reliability. When using certain apps like MS Teams or even on some webpages, the Magic Keyboard flat out stops working. It's not a great experience to be presenting on a call and not be able to type or move the pointer. This has happened to me fairly often and usually at the worst times.
5) Material. This is the least of my issues, but it's just not very pretty or durable for such an expensive device. I have a few big scratches/gouges in the plastic covering even with light usage.

Hope a redesign addresses these.
Yeah... half the reason the Magic Keyboard is so awesome is because you don't need to think about it at all... it just works, and while it's working, it also feels great to use. I totally balked at the price of it initially, but it's seriously one of the best peripherals I own.

Same. I have used it since it first came out last year and it works perfect with my M1 12.9 as well. It has held up really nicely as well, and the extra USB-C port is a major bonus to the MK.
I really love MK, except for it’s weight, however I’ve been experiencing persistent unresponsive behaviour when using Pages app. Any help?
 
All these are great but the software is major limitation, unless all you do is web surfing.
 
The new version of the Brydge keyboard for my 11" iPad M1 2TB is a big jump over the prior version. It has the new feature of supporting the iPad in vertical mode which is handy. Still beats a 13" laptop on the mini "table" on an airline.

BTW. It functions like a Mac but with cellular capability that is still lacking on Apple MacOS devices.

I think negative comments without using the device are pointless. Conjecture versus reality.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GuruZac
The new version of the Brydge keyboard for my 11" iPad M1 2TB is a big jump over the prior version. It has the new feature of supporting the iPad in vertical mode which is handy. Still beats a 13" laptop on the mini "table" on an airline.

BTW. It functions like a Mac but with cellular capability that is still lacking on Apple MacOS devices.

I think negative comments without using the device are pointless. Conjecture versus reality.
When I am done with school, I’m going to go for the 11” iPad Pro with Magic Keyboard combo. I almost sent my 12.9 M1 back in change for the 11” with Magic Keyboard, but I love the mini LED display and the extra screen size is nice for using Split View which I do quite a bit.
 
This video is from August 2020, the 11" Brydge Max+ wasn't even out yet, and the reviews of the 12.9" that I've seen have been positive, stop spreading fake news.

I'll trust the duo who's been reviewing Apple accessories since before you registered here before I trust anyone who uses the term "fake news."
 
If only Apple made a lightweight laptop..
I bought my wife an iPad Air 1 week before the M1 Macbook Air was released. She wanted a keyboard so she went to the Apple store and bought whatever keyboard fit the 2020 iPad Air. Then the M1 was released and between what the IPad + keyboard cost we could have bought the MacBook Air.

IOS apps don’t work well and have trouble upscaling screen size so it probably wouldn’t have been a perfect solution.
 
I bought my wife an iPad Air 1 week before the M1 Macbook Air was released. She wanted a keyboard so she went to the Apple store and bought whatever keyboard fit the 2020 iPad Air. Then the M1 was released and between what the IPad + keyboard cost we could have bought the MacBook Air.

IOS apps don’t work well and have trouble upscaling screen size so it probably wouldn’t have been a perfect solution.
Because I wanted the drawing experience occasionally for my professional use, I got iPad Pro, with MK, thinking it would also be a convincing “laptop” for my wife. The inconsistent app behaviour and the iPad iOS limitations have surprisingly frustrated her to a point she sometimes prefers to do stuff in iPhone.
 
I got a 12.9in iPad Pro and Magic Keyboard case in 2020 but I’m HIGHLY likely to buy the alleged 2022 Macbook Air redesign as soon as it is released.

Work issues a high end MBP to me (about to get a M1 Max 16in soon). For personal uses, I don’t need a lot of laptop anymore. I thought this iPad Pro setup could be that replacement but it is simply inferior to just buying an M1 MBA at this juncture. Worth it just for the bigger trackpad that isn’t so clicky. The M1 transition killed the iPad Pro laptop‘s advantages with battery life and noise (fanless).

Same situation mostly, my job makes sure I have a heavy lift laptop, looking forward to the 14” (I asked for it over the 16”, I’m on call often and it’s easier to carry) M1 Max IT is issuing me in January, but I still do enough personal projects, hobbies mostly, that I need a personal laptop.

I have definitely noticed though that I don’t use my MBA for anything *but* personal light coding projects and such now, my iPad Air has replaced it for nearly anything else personal. I’ll probably pick up the reddesign of the MBA next year to give me that M* boost from my 2020 intel machine laptop-wise, but I definitely don’t need anything more powerful for personal use (and now that I say that watch, Apple will gimp the new MBAs in some way and I’ll end up with a personal MBP :p )
 
All these are great but the software is major limitation, unless all you do is web surfing.
Problem is when you put it with keyboard you tend to use it as a Mac, and it gets frustrating. iPad shines when used as tablet, specially with pencil. Hand notes and revisions work great.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.