Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Buying a Mac Pro Quad Core or 8 Core?

Mac Pros are too expensive to just have as regular computer unless you make money with them or are just a rich kid... nothing wrong with being a richie rich, but most people don't have $6000 internet computers that also kinda suck at Crysis
 
snouter said:
Mac Pros are too expensive to just have as regular computer unless you make money with them or are just a rich kid... nothing wrong with being a richie rich, but most people don't have $6000 internet computers that also kinda suck at Crysis
Click to expand...

Just an opinion with no basis in fact.

So only rich kids or people who make money with a car should buy anything more expensive than a subcompact Kia? Same logic.

I'm beginning to understand why Windows people can't stand Mac people.
 
Roy said:
Just an opinion with no basis in fact.
Click to expand...

My opinion is that you are overly defensive about this for some reason...

buy what you want, it's yours (or your parents) money...

"Most" people do not buy $6000 computers for suring the internet and learning 3d with a Maya crack.

Feel free to your own research and make up your own facts, but I think you will find that the $6000 computer market is very small.
 
snouter said:
My opinion is that you are overly defensive about this for some reason...

buy what you want, it's yours (or your parents) money...

"Most" people do not buy $6000 computers for suring the internet and learning 3d with a Maya crack.

Feel free to your own research and make up your own facts, but I think you will find that the $6000 computer market is very small.
Click to expand...

I've been a Mac person for almost 25 years, but I get tired of defending Mac people who have the elitist attitude that they know what is best for other people based upon their own personal bias.

Absolutely a good answer. (you could have put in also your children's inheritance .)

I agree. It's small, just like the market is for Mac's.
 
I second Roy.

I have done nothing with my Mac Pro besides surfing, gaming, writing documents...


But I feel satisfied with the fact that I have a computer running native Mac OSX that is able to handle any game or application I throw at it, and has performance that will last very long. Plus it is upgradeable.

If you have the money, go for it. Who are other people to judge?
 
snouter said:
So imagine how small the $6000 segment of the small Apple segment is? Now we are getting elite about it.
Click to expand...

Nothing elitist about the $6000 club. It's the attitude of those who are not in the club and who play the elitist attitude that THEY know what is BEST and what to buy for those in the $6000 club. Price example below:

snouter said:
Mac Pros are too expensive to just have as regular computer unless you make money with them or are just a rich kid... nothing wrong with being a richie rich, but most people don't have $6000 internet computers that also kinda suck at Crysis
Click to expand...
 
Roy said:
Nothing elitist about the $6000 club. It's the attitude of those who are not in the club and who play the elitist attitude that THEY know what is BEST and what to buy for those in the $6000 club. Price example below:
Click to expand...

It is ok to be a mac elitist. Anyone that purchased all that mac hardware you have has to be a mac elitist.
 
Shiner said:
It is ok to be a mac elitist. Anyone that purchased all that mac hardware you have has to be a mac elitist.
Click to expand...

I'm an elitist because I didn't purchase an iMac, because I'm not a professional, because I'm a rich kid? I'm not a professional, not a rich kid, and I didn't purchase an iMac. But it's my money, my family is well taken care of, and I like to make my own decisions about my choices on how I spend my money.

My intent, for a long time, was to buy an octocore, but the more I read the more I decided that the octo was not what I wanted after all. (Note: I used "wanted", not "needed". Food, clothing, shelter are needs. No one "needs" a computer). MacWorld magazine's review of the current Mac Pros clinched it for me. The $700 was not an issue. And it really wasn't $700 because more memory was included in the $700.

Maybe I like stimulating the economy to help save your job and to save a small fruit company that only has between 5 and 7 percent of the market.
 
ajbrehm said:
You cannot mix those dimms with the one Apple put in.
Click to expand...

Actually, you can. But you will take a speed hit for doing so. Then again, most users won't notice it because hard drives are always the speed bump, and few people are maxing that out.

Second, if you are using anything that is core scalable, those 16 logical cores have use. Compressor will snag everything, so us video types love being able to compress things in a fraction the time. And if you're into it, the spare cores could be used on Folding@home. Now, while that isn't quite solving the plight of somalian children, it is putting computational power to work on medical research that could speed the discovery of new disease cures. Maybe a stretch, but it's something that the cores could be used for.

The "Who's going to buy a $6,000 computer" argument is a little grating to those of us who edit video. Time is money, speed saves time, therefore that $6,000 computer has real applications for people who use their computer to ply a trade. Even if it's a business you run on the side, as I do, you make money by having a faster computer because time you can spend shooting and working on jobs rather than waiting on your computer is time you can use to make more money. Or go on hikes.
 
snouter said:
I know, we've all been there... :D

chill out, nobody was ever judging you but at least you were easy to read...



:) So, I was right?
Click to expand...

Thanks, I appreciate the comment.

Mac Pros are for anyone who wants to spend the money to buy one. There is no requirement that you have to make money with them or be a rich kid.
 
I fully agree. Buy whatever computer makes you happy. You only live once, and if you decide you want to "drive" a Mac Pro, who is to say you shouldn't??? Go for it, and enjoy the power!

Even though I do use mine for work, I think it is ridiculous that some people criticize enthusiasts that enjoy the great experience of owning a superior piece of computing machinery.
 
Well, I think Roy has there good points.

I am music student. Bought a MacBook Pro (first Mac) in 2007 for music production with Logic 8. Well, I got better and better with my technical music knowledge, so my quality of the music grown up with that and I need now much more CPU performance.iMac is a no-go for me, don't want to explain now why ;-) . I want since a year a Mac Pro. So I am getting with my part time job around 800-900 Dollars a month and I try to live as cheap as I can so that I can get this monster. This July, I want to get a Mac Pro with 2.26 8 Core. I think the Quad would go perfect, but I also think for the future the 8 Core is a better investment (my thoughts and feelings). I want to invest that much money, because I am sure I will can use this mac for a lot of years for music production. And I think, a VERY BIG nice thing about this beast is that everything is running so fast and smooth. You don't need to wait if you load a small programm. It just pops up. On a iMac or MacBook Pro, you'll need to wait 1-4 Seconds. I know its not much in the time of human life, but I it feels so good, that everything is working so smooth and fast and this is so much fun. Even if you don't need the full Power, you notice automatically that everything runs much faster. Also I spend a few hours everyday on the mac so I think it is a good investment. If Quad or Octo, everyone need to decide on his own.
 
Roy said:
I'm an elitist because I didn't purchase an iMac, because I'm not a professional, because I'm a rich kid? I'm not a professional, not a rich kid, and I didn't purchase an iMac. But it's my money, my family is well taken care of, and I like to make my own decisions about my choices on how I spend my money.

My intent, for a long time, was to buy an octocore, but the more I read the more I decided that the octo was not what I wanted after all. (Note: I used "wanted", not "needed". Food, clothing, shelter are needs. No one "needs" a computer). MacWorld magazine's review of the current Mac Pros clinched it for me. The $700 was not an issue. And it really wasn't $700 because more memory was included in the $700.

What made you decide Quad over Octo?
Click to expand...
 
numbersyx said:
Roy said:
I'm an elitist because I didn't purchase an iMac, because I'm not a professional, because I'm a rich kid? I'm not a professional, not a rich kid, and I didn't purchase an iMac. But it's my money, my family is well taken care of, and I like to make my own decisions about my choices on how I spend my money.

My intent, for a long time, was to buy an octocore, but the more I read the more I decided that the octo was not what I wanted after all. (Note: I used "wanted", not "needed". Food, clothing, shelter are needs. No one "needs" a computer). MacWorld magazine's review of the current Mac Pros clinched it for me. The $700 was not an issue. And it really wasn't $700 because more memory was included in the $700.

What made you decide Quad over Octo?
Click to expand...

Remember that I'm not a "professional computer person": meaning that I don't make my living by using a computer and the products I produce from that computer are not my main source of livelihood. I just like nice toys and I can "fix" a Mac (OS X) if I need to, but Windows is too much work to keep going strong without a good bit of work. (At least that has been my experience based upon my Windows workplace and my son needed a Windows machine for his computer ?? degree.)

I don't believe that I will ever buy any of the high end programs that take advantage of the multiple cores. And if and when main stream programs are being sold that take advantage of multiple cores, then I will have been ready for another computer long before that. I also don't do enough family and friends movies to benefit from the extra cores.

I started last night converting my old VHS tape to digital and even doing the conversions my Activity Monitor didn't show my CPU was maxing out. And even when I'm recording, converting, and etc. I can still up my Mac Pro to do other things.

And BTW, I had read so much about how you had to buy this, and you had to have this piece of equipment, and on and on about converting old VHS tapes to digital and at least in my experience that a bunch of crap. I took my 10 old VHS player and a 16 year old tape and had no problems. Hooked the VHS player to my 8 or 9 year old camcorder, hooked my camcorder up to my Mac Pro, opened up iMovie, started the VHS tape, told iMove to Import, and that was all there was to it. No additional software, no converter box. And I had been dreading figuring out what to buy. Now I have lots of VHS tapes I need to digitize. So I've ordered another 1TB hard drive.

I have a good number of songs I've collected over the years, so I convert them back and forth between different formats for various reasons. What used to take me a couple of minutes for each song to convert, my 2009 Mac Pro did each in about 2 seconds. If I was a "Pro", then that quarter of a second different between and Octo and Quad would add up in a year's time and would be lost money. Assuming I'm working 100 percent all the time. (I guess that means the downturn in the economy has not affected computer professionals. Hard to believe, but maybe it's true.)

My Quad sits on 98 percent idle about most all of the time. Only rarely has it gotten down into the 50 percent mark. But I used to drive a Ford XL with a big block 428 C.I.D. and most of the times the horsepower was just sitting around. Perhaps waiting for the next red light to turn green to smoke the tires or doing the quarter mile at the local drag strip. But I still drove it back and forth to work each day and mostly obeyed the speed limit about 98 percent of the time.
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back