Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

iphonesrq

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Aug 31, 2007
391
0
Tampa
Hello I have a MBP (2007 version) it will only hold 2GB of ram, it have 2 sticks of 2GB DDR2 ram....can I use this?

Will it just default to 2GB anyways or will this screw up my MBP?

thanks!
 
Hello I have a MBP (2007 version) it will only hold 2GB of ram, it have 2 sticks of 2GB DDR2 ram....can I use this?

Will it just default to 2GB anyways or will this screw up my MBP?

thanks!

It'll just default to 2GB, the chipset is not designed to handle more therefore it won't handle more.
 
ooops sorry my other computer is a MBP 13" uni --- this is actually a white MB 1.83gHz from 2007 only supports 2GB

If it's a 1.83 core 2 duo whitebook, i have one, and it supports 4GB for sure. I've got 4GB in mine.
 
screen shot

here's a screen shot showing it only supports a max of 2GB
 

Attachments

  • Picture 1.png
    Picture 1.png
    35.9 KB · Views: 107
here's a screen shot showing it only supports a max of 2GB

Is it a Core Duo (as listed in that screenshot) or a Core 2 Duo? This makes a difference.

You mentioned in your post that it was a 2007 model, right? I bought mine in March 07 and it's a Core 2 Duo, and supports 4GB. Not sure when the refresh from CD to C2D happened...
 
Is it a Core Duo (as listed in that screenshot) or a Core 2 Duo? This makes a difference.

You mentioned in your post that it was a 2007 model, right? I bought mine in March 07 and it's a Core 2 Duo, and supports 4GB. Not sure when the refresh from CD to C2D happened...

He's talking about a MacBook, not a MacBook Pro.
 
If the screen shot is correct as to his model, then it's a 2006 MacBook, and only supports 2 GB.

Please go to System Profiler, and tell us the model number from there.
 
Is it a Core Duo (as listed in that screenshot) or a Core 2 Duo? This makes a difference.

You mentioned in your post that it was a 2007 model, right? I bought mine in March 07 and it's a Core 2 Duo, and supports 4GB. Not sure when the refresh from CD to C2D happened...

If you bought a MacBook in March, 2007, it was either MA660LL/A, MA700LL/A or MA701LL/A, none of which support 4GB. They support a max of 2GB, according to Apple, but will actually use up to 3GB. This is also the model that introduced the Core 2 Duo. They were introduced in Nov. 2006 and discontinued in May, 2007. This is the OP's model, as it was the only Core 2 Duo available with a 1.83GHz processor.

The MacBook introduced in May, 2007 also supported a max of 2GB RAM. It wasn't until Nov. 2007 that a 13" MacBook was introduced that supported 4GB of RAM.
 
If you bought a MacBook in March, 2007, it was either MA660LL/A, MA700LL/A or MA701LL/A, none of which support 4GB. They support a max of 2GB, according to Apple, but will actually use up to 3GB. This is also the model that introduced the Core 2 Duo. They were introduced in Nov. 2006 and discontinued in May, 2007. This is the OP's model, as it was the only Core 2 Duo available with a 1.83GHz processor.

The MacBook introduced in May, 2007 also supported a max of 2GB RAM. It wasn't until Nov. 2007 that a 13" MacBook was introduced that supported 4GB of RAM.

I really don't want this to turn into an argument, as I'm just trying to help the OP. That being said, I've attached a screenshot for the Macbook I was discussing earlier.

Macbook 2,1 1.83 C2D, 4G of RAM.

This profile also matches the one OP just posted, so looks like the 4GB upgrade should work for you.
 
I really don't want this to turn into an argument, as I'm just trying to help the OP. That being said, I've attached a screenshot for the Macbook I was discussing earlier.

Macbook 2,1 1.83 C2D, 4G of RAM.

This profile also matches the one OP just posted, so looks like the 4GB upgrade should work for you.

Kindly post a shot of your Activity Monitor, showing System Memory:
Picture 1.JPG

From http://support.apple.com/kb/SP23:
Picture 2.JPG

By the way, I'm not arguing. It's just that your claim is contrary to published information, both from Apple and other sites, regarding specs for your model. If their information is inaccurate, it would be helpful to know.
 
Kindly post a shot of your Activity Monitor, showing System Memory:

From http://support.apple.com/kb/SP23:

By the way, I'm not arguing. It's just that your claim is contrary to published information, both from Apple and other sites, regarding specs for your model. If their information is inaccurate, it would be helpful to know.

Took a look at activity monitor and it does indeed return the 3GB. (By the way, totally skimmed through your post where you mentioned unofficial support of 3GB and missed that bit until reading again right now)

Not sure where'd I'd seen support for 4GB when I originally bought the upgrade. Luckily the price was really good on the 2x2GB I got, so the upgrade from 512 was a good move regardless.

So I guess to OP, it'll take the 4GB. About This Mac will make you excited to think you've got it. But in the end, 3GB will be in use.
 
From the OWC website:

http://eshop.macsales.com/shop/memory/MacBook/DDR2/

"***MacBook Core 2 Duo 1.83GHz and 2.16GHz (late/2006-Mid/2007) models are able to accept a matched pair of 2GB modules for 4.0GB total, but only fully utilize the first 3.0GB of installed memory. Even so, even with these systems, there is some benefit to having the matched pair of 4.0GB installed (View Benchmarks)."

So installing 4 GB gets you 3 GB as shown by another reply.
 
From the OWC website:

http://eshop.macsales.com/shop/memory/MacBook/DDR2/

"***MacBook Core 2 Duo 1.83GHz and 2.16GHz (late/2006-Mid/2007) models are able to accept a matched pair of 2GB modules for 4.0GB total, but only fully utilize the first 3.0GB of installed memory. Even so, even with these systems, there is some benefit to having the matched pair of 4.0GB installed (View Benchmarks)."

So installing 4 GB gets you 3 GB as shown by another reply.

interesting! so how do i know if i can install 4GB in mine? this is getting confusing! can i just install & check the activity monitor on memory??
 
interesting! so how do i know if i can install 4GB in mine? this is getting confusing! can i just install & check the activity monitor on memory??

The point is, you can install 4GB, but your Mac will only use a maximum of 3GB. The other GB is wasted.
 
interesting! so how do i know if i can install 4GB in mine? this is getting confusing! can i just install & check the activity monitor on memory??

It's not confusing. If you have a MacBook Core 2 Duo 1.83GHz then the above applies to you.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.