Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Can't decide between previous generation U15 or a NEW U15...

5

5630745

Cancelled
Original poster
May 30, 2007
513
24
I'm trying to list the potential pro's and cons between the U15 first and current generations. I'd like to purchase one.

Pro's on the previous 15: Removable battery, RAM, and HD. Second card for graphics. PRICE!!!

Con: 6GB Cap. Older.

In theory? I could extend the life of this machine far longer by swapping in and out components. And the current savings make this an attractive buy. SL should run better with the second card.

Just released 15 pro's: 8GB. Better Battery life. Better screen?

Con: Battery is stuck. Base model lacks the second card. Too new for any reviews yet...
 
I have thought about this myself having the first generation u15. I don't need the extended battery life as I don't take this one away from my desk too often. Being able to easily replace the battery still appeals to me. I have 4gb of memory now and can't see needing anymore for my applications. Screen on my is super and I have the two graphics options. The new entry level u15 does not. But the bottom line is you can get the first generation u15 as a refurb for 1349. If I wanted to sell mine I'd lose a ton of money and that enters in to any decision to move to the newer model. So, in my opinion I'd go first generation and save some cash

bmstrong said:
I'm trying to list the potential pro's and cons between the U15 first and current generations. I'd like to purchase one.

Pro's on the previous 15: Removable battery, RAM, and HD. Second card for graphics. PRICE!!!

Con: 6GB Cap. Older.

In theory? I could extend the life of this machine far longer by swapping in and out components. And the current savings make this an attractive buy. SL should run better with the second card.

Just released 15 pro's: 8GB. Better Battery life. Better screen?

Con: Battery is stuck. Base model lacks the second card. Too new for any reviews yet...
Click to expand...
 
Philflow said:
snip

If you're playing games it's another story though.
Click to expand...

Exactly why I bought the refurb UMBP @ $1349. I wanted to stop carrying two laptops. My Sony and my MB are on eBay now. My new UMBP with the 9600 should handle the same games I had working on the Sony's ATI HD3650. If you want to play games the 9600 is the way to go.

Cheers,
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back