When we were looking for a [used] car last month, it was more reasonable to buy a newer Civic as it would have only costed a few grand more than a 2-3 year old Civic. Can't remember what the numbers were, but I think it was $17-18k for a used Civic but $21-22k for a new one. So I guess it depends on what car it is ... but regardless it is surprisingly true sometimes.
OP i think you should consider a used Suburu if you aren't in a rush. Used cars really aren't that bad sometimes. But if it's like the case with the Civic where which a newer one will only cost you a little more, then I'd just go with a newer one.
That's what I was saying. With the increase in demand for used vehicles, the prices have also gone up. Normally, I would never touch a brand new vehicle, but sometimes it makes sense. A few years ago, when GM was offering their employee pricing, a friend of mine was able to buy a brand new Chevy truck for cheaper than a 2 year old used model he had been looking at. Incentives on new cars may end up making it cheaper. Also, if there is a major upgrade for the new models, it may be worth it. In your case, the 2012 Civic has an improved drivetrain that may make it worth it. Another example is the Ford Focus. The 2012 Focus is a totally different car than the 2011 model, and is much better.