The Totallee Clear (Soft) passes the pinky test. What I've noticed is that the cases that pass the pinky test for me are either a soft material (like, silicone) or the case can't have too big of an opening for the lightning cable. The wider the hole, the sharper the edges are. A wide opening creates a thin surface that acts like those orange plastic blades on my pinky finger. The case also can't be too heavy because then it will add extra weight on the pinky, pushing the "blade" into my pinky. Another case I suggest is the Apple leather case. It might be sharp at first, but as you use it, the leather will wear out and the material around the opening for the lightning cable will get softer.