If the iPhone 5 turns out to be nothing but a stretched out iPhone 4, there's gonna be a major customer bleed to sexier looking Androids or Windows phones this go around.
The iPhone has become so ubiquitous that every schmo you see walkin around has got one. As one of those dudes who bought the original the day it came out I can say it's been a loooong time since you could pull out your iPhone and have people's heads turn.
And given that this "redesign" is going to be what we're stuck with for the next 2 years with the 5 and 5S, I don't think Apple'd be positioning itself well in this increasingly competitive market.
The iPhone 5 HAS to be a sexier redesign than this. And I think it will be... (fingers crossed)
Vanity at it's finest!
Who gives a crap what phone you have and let alone if it turns heads? Jesus, all phones look alike now anyway. Flat, brick like devices. Literally, all the same. Only way to tell them apart is to hold it. If you want to turn heads, carry around a bag phone.