Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

93BlackSVT

macrumors member
Original poster
Nov 2, 2010
58
0
I have a DVD of my wife and I's wedding and would like to make a copy of it. Are there any free programs out there that will let me do this? If so, what are they and any assistance with the program would be much appreciated!
 
I personally use Handbrake for my personal projects. It's very user friendly so you don't have to be a computer engineer to use it. Did I mention it's free?
 
It does not do what the OP wants though, that is what Disk Utility is for.



No.

You can take a DVD and copy it to your desktop and then copy it to another dvd. It may be easier to do so directly with disk utility but Handbrake can do it. Of course, I write my DVD's in MP4 format. If you're looking for regular dvd format you can also check out iDVD. Again, disk utility would be easiest for you.
 
You can take a DVD and copy it to your desktop and then copy it to another dvd. It may be easier to do so directly with disk utility but Handbrake can do it. Of course, I write my DVD's in MP4 format. If you're looking for regular dvd format you can also check out iDVD. Again, disk utility would be easiest for you.

Handbrake is not for copying video DVDs, it actually just transcodes the MPEG-2 video to MPEG-4 (H.264) after the video DVD is ripped with another application or Handbrake (+VLC) itself.
And just copying a video DVD's content via Finder, even if the video DVD is not copy-protected (called CSS), will not work either, as burning a new DVD from the copied data will just create a data DVD.
Using Disk Utility ensures, that the user creates a video DVD copy from a video DVD, as a video DVD is not the same as a data DVD.
 
I havent used it in a while because i like macdvdripper pro and wondershare but cant you just use handbrake along with burn...both those are free.
 
I havent used it in a while because i like macdvdripper pro and wondershare but cant you just use handbrake along with burn...both those are free.

Can or can't?
No to can, as it would include two transcoding (re-compresison) process instead of none.
Using Handbrake to transcode to MPEG-4 (from MPEG-2) will result in limited image quality loss. Then using burn to make a video DVD will again need transcoding to MPEG-2 (from MPEG-4), which again will introduce image loss.

Sorry to be so adamant about it, but for my work I had to copy dozens, if not even hundreds, of non-copy-protect DVDs (which were created in-house) to other DVDs, and the simplest and fastest way was via Disk Utility.

If copy protection is involved, one has to use a ripping application like MacTheRipper (version 2.6.6 is free) and then Burn or Toast Titanium to burn the resulting VIDEO_TS folder as video DVD.

Again, a video DVD is NOT the same as a data DVD.
 
Can or can't?
No to can, as it would include two transcoding (re-compresison) process instead of none.
Using Handbrake to transcode to MPEG-4 (from MPEG-2) will result in limited image quality loss. Then using burn to make a video DVD will again need transcoding to MPEG-2 (from MPEG-4), which again will introduce image loss.

Sorry to be so adamant about it, but for my work I had to copy dozens, if not even hundreds, of non-copy-protect DVDs (which were created in-house) to other DVDs, and the simplest and fastest way was via Disk Utility.

If copy protection is involved, one has to use a ripping application like MacTheRipper (version 2.6.6 is free) and then Burn or Toast Titanium to burn the resulting VIDEO_TS folder as video DVD.

Again, a video DVD is NOT the same as a data DVD.

Ahhh I did not know that's good info. im usually ripping copyright protected content but its good to know
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.