Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Tumbleweed666

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Mar 20, 2009
1,761
141
Near London, UK.
Reason I'm looking for free is not because I'm a cheapskate but I have no need to recover the data on the disk in question (its backed up elsewhere and its not the system disk) and it costs much more to buy the usual suspects like DiskWarrior than to just buy a new disk.
Its a 2TB disk, with two partitions, one of which is accessible and works, the other is greyed out in Disk Utility and cannot be mounted or diagnosed or otherwise accessed.
So more likely its software, but it might be hardware so theres no logic in spending about 2x on an app I need for a one-off repair that might not work, might as well "fix" it for sure with a new disk.
I'm quite happy to wipe it and start again.
TIA
 
If you have the data backed up somewhere else, it will be far FAR easier to just go to the backup and restore from there.

Doing so will save you A LOT of time, trouble, and headaches.
 
Whatever you do, backup the data on the readable partition first and test the backup to confirm it is good.
 
Whatever you do, backup the data on the readable partition first and test the backup to confirm it is good.

Thanks. Its already backed up in multiple places and this whole disk is just a second TM disk (it was the first).
Looks like there are no answers so I'm going to try plugging it into a PC and seeing if i can nuke it from that and if that works I'll then try a reformat back on the Mac.
 
...I'm going to try plugging it into a PC and seeing if i can nuke it from that and if that works I'll then try a reformat back on the Mac.
That has worked for me in the past when macOS Disk Utility can't deal with the drive/partition. In those cases, I've had to use Windows' Drive Manager to access the drive, repartitioning it there. After that, I reformatted the drive using Windows, usually as exFAT so the Mac will see it.

I've done this several times, interestingly two of the drives were munged by TM.
 
OK we'll see how this goes, I've managed to erase and reinstate it using "DiskUtil" via Terminal. Which helpfully was pointed to below here in "similar threads" under "alternatives to disk utlity" - Thanks HenryAZ.
If it survives a few weeks then it was "just" software" it it fails again I'll bin it and buy a new one.
TM is currently backing up to it.
DiskUtil reported what sounded like logical errors, things pointing in the wrong places but it wasn't able to repair hence the reformat.
Thanks all.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.