Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

AppleGoat

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Oct 14, 2010
655
8
For those of you who have been following my Crucial M4 saga, the most recent chapter is the delivery of a new one. Without having the option of swapping out out the M4 for a 470, I was fenced into getting another one (even though I never suspected the original was defective.) For a moment, things were looking up. The replacement drive was shipped in a nice box and the Crucial packaging was not smashed in like the original. Furthermore, the sticker on the replacement drive said it had firmware revision 0002. The "hmm, perhaps this may work, after all" frame of mind was short lived. As soon as I launched OS, it beach balled. So far, the experience has been the same as the old drive. Ugh. Now what.

The problems seem to lie with my system. All those rumors circulating that the earliest manufactured 2011 MacBook Pros have faulty SATA III ports may have some merit, after all. If that is the problem, how exactly would one go about getting Apple to own up to their mistake and fix my machine? What responsibility would be of theirs to look into a problem affecting a third-party drive, undoubtedly the Apple stock HDs work. Additionally, if I were to have the computer tended to, the drive would most likely behave like a naughty child in front of his parents while his babysitter tries to convince them that he gave her trouble.

Before installing the replacement drive, I took a photo of my SATA cable. Does anything look awry? It is bent, as you can see. Would this adversely affect the performance of a SATA II drive? Still many questions, but the course seems chartered for SATA II.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20110823_220305.jpg
    IMG_20110823_220305.jpg
    265.8 KB · Views: 158
I'm afraid you're right. SATA II seems like your best option now. You can certainly try to replace your MBP, but is it worth the effort?

The Samsung 470, Crucial C300, or Kingston V+100 seem like your best options.
 
I don't understand why my drive works at all if there's something wrong with my SATA III connection.
 
More importantly, why does my drive post sufficient - great benchmark numbers?
 
Hi, I'm new to the club... 2011 macbook pro I7 quad 17" w/ M4 256gb... just installed today, learning about the beachball first hand! this looks like a headache... just got my first one.
 
I'm one of the early adopters of the Crucial M4 256GB version. In the beginning, the beach balls were driving me crazy. However, they've posted new firmware 0002 and 0009, the former already fixed the beach ball issue and the latter an improvement upgrade. I'm currently on it's firmware 0009 and without beach ball anymore.
 
I'm one of the early adopters of the Crucial M4 256GB version. In the beginning, the beach balls were driving me crazy. However, they've posted new firmware 0002 and 0009, the former already fixed the beach ball issue and the latter an improvement upgrade. I'm currently on it's firmware 0009 and without beach ball anymore.

Yeah, It's just bizarre that I still have the problem, sporadically, after updating the Firmware.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.