Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Curved Phones = Gimmick
- Thread starter MBX
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Gimmicky as long as it's just a curved phone, but the technology required to build it is the beginning of bendable phones and imagine a phone that you could slap around your wrist and use as a watch, then remove it and use it as a fully functional phone. Dunno, but in my mind it seems like a pretty cool idea. Maybe I should patent it.
I've watched some video reviews on curves phones and most don't think it's a gimmick. One review claims typing feel more natural and effortless. Others say looking at the screen(like watching a video or gamming) you won't noticed it's curved. There was one review that mentioned a con about viewing from an angle, but that can just be that specific phone and not all curved phones. There was also another con about not being able to utilize the curved space, resulting in smaller battery.
I really have no opinon about curved phones until I see and hold one myself.
I really have no opinon about curved phones until I see and hold one myself.
Seems as though the following items were construed the same way, when they came out:
Finger print scanner on a phone
NFC
capacitive, touch-screen keyboard
Mobile apps
digital wallet
Gotta start somewhere, right? Oh yeah, and all the rumors are pointing to Apple going after a bendable or wraparound larger display on the iPhone 6. So if the iPhone gets it, will you still consider it 'gimmicky'? Just curious.
I think its awesome. A curved screen results in less reflections in the light and the way that LG phone can flex under pressure and go back to its original shape is pretty awesome.
Also, phones with huge screens were once considered (and still are in certain crowds) a gimmick. Which phone do you have again OP?
Also, phones with huge screens were once considered (and still are in certain crowds) a gimmick. Which phone do you have again OP?
Hmm seems many here like it then.
I just don't see a point in curvy phones. Maybe I just like it to be straight to display the UI perfectly. But for mainstream regular consumers the little difference in the screen bending UI isn't an issue.
I agree though for a smart watch it's well applied and necessary.
I just don't see a point in curvy phones. Maybe I just like it to be straight to display the UI perfectly. But for mainstream regular consumers the little difference in the screen bending UI isn't an issue.
I agree though for a smart watch it's well applied and necessary.
it's a gimmick because the current batch of phones are curved just to show they can do it like someone pointed out previously. i have only seen the example of using the curvature to skip song tracks by laying it flat on a table and tilting in various directions...
same with iOS 7's parallax effect. it was fun for the first couple of days and then i switched it off cause it was useless
fits better? less reflections? more natural to type? how bout quit making phones with super huge screens? i can palm a basketball but i can just about barely type on my Nexus 5 one handed without the phone feeling like its about to drop
same with iOS 7's parallax effect. it was fun for the first couple of days and then i switched it off cause it was useless
fits better? less reflections? more natural to type? how bout quit making phones with super huge screens? i can palm a basketball but i can just about barely type on my Nexus 5 one handed without the phone feeling like its about to drop
That is designed for two-handed operation. If you want to use just one hand, buy a small phone.
I had a curved phone, then went to a flat screen, and the curved phone just felt a little bit better and a little but more natural. Not enough where I'd notice it on a daily basis, but enough where it I stop to think about it, I can tell you which I prefer.
It's not groundbreaking, for sure, but it's the little things all put together that make a phone a joy to use - a responsive UI, screens that can be used with gloves, wireless charging, NFC, and yes - curved screens.
It's not groundbreaking, for sure, but it's the little things all put together that make a phone a joy to use - a responsive UI, screens that can be used with gloves, wireless charging, NFC, and yes - curved screens.
I think it's more a proof of concept. Right now I'd call it useless. But the idea is going to lead to other advancements. The smart phone market is so plump right now we are at a point where the end user has become the R&D. It's cheaper for some companies to just rush out a device and see what sticks for next time.
Remember when 3D cameras were supposed to be a big thing for phones? Thank god that one didn't stick.
Remember when 3D cameras were supposed to be a big thing for phones? Thank god that one didn't stick.
My Nexus S 4G screen was curved.
It's a gimmick at worst, dubious at best based upon my experience.
It's a gimmick at worst, dubious at best based upon my experience.
Thank nothing. I still want a 3D phone.
I bought a 3D camera with auto stereoscopic screen and it is really cool.
I also have a 3D monitor.
This kind of product is what is needed when you have weak sales because people start seeing no reason to get new gear. But it should be properly marketed.
Now there is a lot of people with 3DTVs.
Has anyone questioned why the LG Flex and Galaxy Round curve in different directions (horizontally and vertically). If it had any advantage all phones would curve in the same direction (ie. horizontally to better fit the pocket or improve grip, or whatever benefit curve had). I don't see any benefit to curved screens. Curved screens on CRT TVs and monitors where replaced long ago by Flat front CRT such as Trinitron, then then Plasma and LCD. Curved displays on old TVs distorted the images.
No. It makes sense.
If you put the phone in your front pants pocket or inner jacket pocket, buy the Samsung.
If you put it in your outer coat pocket, buy the LG.
If you put it in your back pocket, buy either the LG or Samsung depending on the direction that you prefer, assuming it fits.
If you put it in your front shirt pocket, buy the Samsung.
Other pockets, check.
----------
I think the shops need some hard flat seats and some untethered dummies.
Last edited:
It's a gimmick, probably the most apparent one I've ever seen. If someone actually buys this phone specifically because it's curved they aren't the sharpest tool in the shed.
Now FOLDABLE screens, that's a different story. Foldable screens will truly change the smartphone/tablet environment IMO.
Now FOLDABLE screens, that's a different story. Foldable screens will truly change the smartphone/tablet environment IMO.
Curved phones are gimmicky because they are only going to exist because the phones are getting bigger and harder to hold. And the only reason the phones are getting bigger, is so that they can stick a bigger battery in them because of 4G LTE.
3D phones? There was two of them already by HTC and LG.
3D phones? There was two of them already by HTC and LG.
Yes, there were already 3D phones, but besides the 3D, nothing I would buy.
There's nothing current.
The curves of the Nexus S and Galaxy Nexus were very slight and not the same as the G Flex or Galaxy Round. The Nexus devices had curved glass, the new LG and Samsung have curved displays.
Anyway, these phones are the stepping stones to bendable phones...which will hopefully be more useful.
I get what you're saying... but what about people who don't necessarily always place their phone in the same exact pocket every time? Which is to say, everyone I know. Yes I'm a left pocket guy, but sometimes it's in my car dock, on my desk, or in my breast pocket. Oddly enough, the "slate" style that basically every phone uses is pretty versatile for all those situations.
I don't think anyone is trying to curve a screen thinking "wow, now it will conform to a certain pocket!"