It's a little more complicated...
The iBook I bought in May 04 and lived at a different place, namly in Barstow in the beautiful California High Desert. I was the one most likely who screwed it up, I disconnected my dv camera at least once without dismounting. In 05 my hd(most likely scenario) gave out more and more(even though the diagnosis wasn't totally clear). I didn't want to spend 350$ for something that might or might not work so I let it sit until recently when I realised a number of things I missed and bought the Ondago hd(even if that didn't work I still had an fine external hd).
Meanwhile, in september 06, I bought the inspiron laptop(the same in Apple, it goes without saying, would have cost exactly double...) and regretably a few days ago(I'm using it in cramped quaters here and the powercord was dangling much wider and different from usual) after I put it on the desk I snagged the powercord with my foot and down it went-broken lcd(and in all fairness, unlike apple support, dell reacted beautifully and went down to 318(everything, including tax, included) to pick it up, fix it and send it back, even though I didn't have accidental warranty.
So, it could be that there was something different or in adition to the hd in the iBook there when it stopped working(even though the external hd seemed to have done the job beautifully).
The monitor finally that I'm using here belongs to the organisation I'm working at for the time being.
So, yes, it is a bit devastading to going from the wealth of to good notebooks to the famine of none for 2 weeks, but really, I have to blame myself mostly. Even though it should be pointed out more clearly everywhere how important correct dismounting is.