She had the iphone 4 and dropped it off a balcony 2 months after recieving it. One of her friends had a iphone 3 they were not using and gave it to her. Well she broke that one too! The problem is we are under a 2 year contract, do you know if I can just buy a cheap att phone that just does text and calling and drop the Data plan with out penalty? Or does anyone know of a cheap phone that will do data with Att that I can put some real restrictions on as far as time of use for the phone texting and Data? Thanks!