I'm finally joining the world of iPhones with my 4S. I just can't decide on what case to use. I have a Defender for my Atrix (work phone) and part of me wants to get another Defender for the iPhone because I know the Defender works marvelously (I've dropped my Atrix several times). However, I keep the Atrix on the beltclip for work, the 4S will be in my pocket. I worry about the Defender being too bulky for my pocket. I've been examining the CandyShell and the Commuter closely. I like the form factor of the CandyShell better, but I like the fact that the Commuter has Apple logo proudly displayed and I think the gel would have a little more shock absorption than the CandyShell's inner material. Anyone ever done comparisons? What do you think?