My first iPhone 3G (which I replaced in-store after I got it because of its' horrible build quality and screen) had a lot of scratches on the metal bezel and a few minor ones on the side of the metal. My second and current iPhone 3G came with two scratches and a nick in the metal. They were all there when I got it, and I haven't caused any at all in the last month and a half. The scratches that it came with sort of piss me off since I'm careful to not scratch it, but I got one of the better screens on this one. I've kept it so I don't risk getting a worse screen or other problems...