Disable VM Seems to Speed Up Lion

t,ftfy

Get an SSD or something...!

 

I have a Seagate Momentus XT "hybrid" 500 GB 7200 RPM / 4 GB SSD drive and 4 GB of RAM and my early 2008 Macbook running 10.7.1 is positively zippy without touching any VM settings. And I can still rip or burn a CD or DVD if I feel like it as my superdrive is working just fine.

Another option is to go with a 60 GB SSD internal (which is plenty for OS and basic apps), pop your larger drive into one of those $10 USB to SATA cases and leave your optical bay alone.

 

Do you know anything about how Lion allocates memory? Aside from what Activity Monitor tells you. And aside from what lays spout all over the interwebs?

If you don't really have a solid fundamental understanding of memory allocation, OS X's abilities in this area, or what exactly virtual memory is for (and how Lion handles it), you had best put things back the way they were.

VM is used (for the majority) only when you run out of RAM. In some cases the OS will place small things there to balance RAM, system integrity, and performance. It's smart about it, but more importantly, it will appease the programs in this area. Do you know what happens when you reach that point, but the OS is not allowed to allocate things there (because you disabled it)? Or independent, 3rd party apps when they request this? Disabling VM is like not wearing a condom during sex. You can get away with it only for so long...

Seriously, it's only fast in your head. Put it this way: Do you think you're smarter than all the Apple engineers that worked on OS X through the years? I know, I know, a lot of questions, but seriously. There are two rampant topics here at MR: i) Lion sucks and ii) My memory is all gone, and it's just getting ridiculous. Next people are gonna put racing stripes on their MBPs and post about how much "snappier" it is.

Oh and if you want to shut me up, post up some numbers. I want to see data on the speed. Not just reboots, but app launches and metrics on in-app performance for various tasks using to the milli-second timing. After all, would you take a drug where some dude just said, "yeah it works." Of course not! Not looking for subjective data (Hey, it seems fast)... but cold, hard, objective facts!

 

Really? You were playing around in Onyx and decided to disable VM, but you're telling me you have a very good understanding of how it works? Really?!?

And it's more of an experiment (read: do you have a solid and very good understanding of what an experiment actually IS) but you aren't going to collect data? Really?!?

Might want to change your thread topic to: Playing around with VM in Lion rather than Disable VM = Fast Lion or people might, you know, get the wrong idea that there's someone making a claim, or even remotely qualified at the helm, when we know only one of those things is true!

 

Are you qualified to determine that the system is not working right or did Apple share some special information with you saying that it wasn't working right? It could be working exactly as designed and if that is the case I'm not sure why you would think that you know better than the designers. I would be very carefull about changing how the core of Mac OS was designed to work since it could have adverse effects with all parts of the system. I do think that the thread title is very misleading since without proof this whole thing can be attributed to the placebo effect.

 

Because apple engineers never make mistakes since they are perfect and have an IQ above 300 as well right?

Geez get off this guys back, there might indeed be a problem with how Lion handles VM, haven't noticed or experienced it in both of my machines but one has 12GB of ram and the other only 4GB but with an SSD.

There's nothing wrong with tinkering with a system you know? sometimes it doesn't just work.

 

I find your results very interesting, no doubt.
And it's cool that you did try this and posted them.

But, as others have said, switching off virtual memory can only cause severe problems in the long run, regardless of how much RAM you have.
If anything, it gives you a taste of how it would be like to have more RAM installed along with an SSD.

On a production machine, I'd still strongly advise against it...
"Don't try this at home"

 

I have 8GB in my MBP, and I disabled VM on my machine a while back. While the results did seem to support that the machine was mildly faster(read:NOT mild blowing) it also seemed to cause some quirkiness. The most noticeable was that after waking from sleep, the browser literally had static, like TV snow, in place of almost all images and flash/html5 objects. ONLY a reboot would correct this. There were other quirks as well, but nothing you would throw a fit over. Ultimately I decided that rebooting my machine to fix the browser after waking from sleep was negating any increased speed I might have found and I put it back to normal.

 

"So when I downloaded OnyX for Lion, I was looking through the options and saw that it had a button for disabling virtual memory. Since my MacBook has 6 GB RAM, I've played around with the idea in my head for a while now, but never got around to actually doing it. I decided to try it and see what happens."

Could you clarify exactly _where_ in the new version of Oynx you found the option to do this?

Perhaps I'm missing something, but I launched Oynx, browsed through all the options I could find, and could find nothing that would let me turn VM off.

Where is it?

 

yeah, good question. i've been using onyx since forever, and have never seen this...

 

I'm far from knowledgeable about memory management .... But aren't some apps/programs/services written to use VM?

I use to do shutoff VM on my Win 2000 server and no problems. So if it makes things a bit snappier with out any problems, why not

 

and so it is...never explored this before (not sure i want to LOL)...
but it IS there as an option...

 

I'm on iThinker on this... If apple engineers are perfect and smart enough. Then why they release bugfixes? The man just want to share some tweaks... Peace

 

It's not in his head

http://hints.macworld.com/article.php?story=201106020948369

Has been done before and will be done again. Honestly if I crash a few times but have better performance 99% of the time then it's worth it. My 2.53ghz i5 MBP has felt so slow since upgrading to Lion, disabling VM has brought it back to life...

 

I had dynamic pager disabled ever since I bought 8gigs of ram and I never had an issue. Lion's memory management is definitely bugged with dynamic pager on it fills my ram until the machine gets snail slow. There is already another thread about the same thing.

 

Hi, just curious -- still everything ok without vm? I've also been playing with the idea of disabling it on my MBP w/8GB and Lion...

 

just did that (disabled the swap)

just hate how stupid it is about swapping things to disk when there is plenty of memory available... let's see how it goes.

main memory hogs here are VMs, usually 2 gig, usually no more than 2 open at a time (so, 4gb). host has 8gb of RAM.

when opening and closing VMs it tended to swap out vmware's memory which of courses make the VM run like a pig until you reboot. looking at the vm stats you see 8GB of swap being used, and lots of free system memory. just stupid.

cheers