Do I need an iPad Pro or an MacBook?

CatherineVeraGat

Suspended
Original poster
May 6, 2017
154
48
I'm thinking of getting an iPad Pro or an MacBook. If I buy an iPad Pro it will have 256GB of storage, and I will buy the Apple Keyboard and Apple Pencil. For the MacBook, 256GB of storage and 8GB of memory is a must. If it supports the Apple Pencil then I will buy the. Apple Pencil. For my device I will be using Photoshop, Illustrations, Word, photo design apps that I can make 3D renderings of devices. So what do you guys think, Will I be better off with an iPad Pro or an MacBook?

(MacBooks that I would buy is the 12 inch MacBook, or the MacBook Pro without Touch Bar 13.3 in version)
 

Stefan johansson

macrumors 65816
Apr 13, 2017
1,294
607
Sweden
MacBook Pro,with a Wacom device for photo editing,works with both Photoshop and pixelmator. With the Wacom plate,you also get a suitable pencil.
 

maflynn

Moderator
Staff member
May 3, 2009
66,940
33,924
Boston
I will be using Photoshop, Illustrations, Word, photo design apps
Are the iOS apps just as powerful and feature rich as the OS X versions? I know Word is not, and I think PS has less features as well.

Personally, I'd say a MBP is a better option but I may be biased
 

Fishrrman

macrumors Core
Feb 20, 2009
19,927
6,978
One more vote for the MacBook.

iOS gives you no workable finder or file system, things you get as a matter of course with a MacBook and the Mac OS. Can you live without such things?
 
  • Like
Reactions: ignatius345

dwfaust

macrumors 603
Jul 3, 2011
6,410
7,274
iPads are useless. They are for kids. If you want productivity get a computer.
Not necessarily true. For the OP's situation, I would go with the MacBook Pro option, but for many, the iPad is a viable alternative... and substantially more that just a "toy for kids".
 

RootBeerMan

macrumors 65816
Jan 3, 2016
1,460
5,247
Another vote for the Macbook, here. It will serve your needs better than the iPad, even if it will cost more. It's much more robust for the apps you want to use.
 

Lawzen

macrumors member
Apr 28, 2017
45
19
I think the majority of people here will side with the MacBook for what you want to do ;)
Out of all the years I've used computers, a Mac has never disappointed. If you get a Mac, there might even be some features you figure along the way that can further your capabilities.
 

ApfelKuchen

macrumors 68040
Aug 28, 2012
3,760
2,339
Between the coasts
It's all about the software. If there aren't iOS apps capable of doing what you plan to do, then Mac it is.

I'm really tired of "(iOS doesn't have) a workable finder or file system." It certainly does, as long as you're using cloud-based storage - iCloud Drive, DropBox, etc. IMO, anyone with a portable device who is not constantly syncing/backing up to the cloud in this day and age is just asking for misery at some point down the road.

If you'll still have a desktop computer in addition to the portable, then you may find iPad Pro to be enough to satisfy your portable needs - not everyone needs 100% of their desktop capabilities when they're away from the desktop, and the extra portability and ease of use may mean you carry (and use) the iPad more (and in different ways) than you would have used the MacBook. However, if it will be your only computer-like device, it may not be enough.
 

appleofmyibook

macrumors regular
May 31, 2016
106
177
I'm thinking of getting an iPad Pro or an MacBook. If I buy an iPad Pro it will have 256GB of storage, and I will buy the Apple Keyboard and Apple Pencil. For the MacBook, 256GB of storage and 8GB of memory is a must. If it supports the Apple Pencil then I will buy the. Apple Pencil. For my device I will be using Photoshop, Illustrations, Word, photo design apps that I can make 3D renderings of devices. So what do you guys think, Will I be better off with an iPad Pro or an MacBook?

(MacBooks that I would buy is the 12 inch MacBook, or the MacBook Pro without Touch Bar 13.3 in version)
The iPad isn't as bad as everyone's making out to be. I think for productivity the MacBook is probably the better option as it's not as 'limited', but in saying that, I also think Apple does an incredible job with Adobe support and especially the Pencil on the Pro. I have both and I tend to use the iPad more with the creative suite of products than the MacBook. That said, with the iPad I would only recommend the 12.9 - cops soooo much from people but really is a magnificent device.
 

CatherineVeraGat

Suspended
Original poster
May 6, 2017
154
48
I'm leaning towards getting a MacBook Pro because an iPad doesn't have all the features that is found on apps that we can get on the MacBook Pro. And the iPad has an 'limited' operating system that doesn't meet the needs for most people. An iPad is just an "bigger iPhone". No wonder why iPad sales are going down. Thank you for all for answering my question.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ignatius345

merkinmuffley

macrumors 6502a
Dec 3, 2010
615
581
You need a Macbook pro, don't even consider an IPad for that mix of apps you mentioned. I went down that path, it's a waste of time and money.
 

Samuelsan2001

macrumors 604
Oct 24, 2013
7,694
2,123
To be honest if you want to be able to draw on it then you may be better off going with a surface book that has a touchscreen that detaches for work with a stylus. If not its a Wacom or an iPad pro to add that feature to your macbook pro and the money starts stacking up. Not my way to advocate a surface I am not keen myself but it seems to be the device that fits your particular niche best.
 

MaraviRasmussen

macrumors newbie
May 3, 2017
21
2
United States
I'm thinking of getting an iPad Pro or an MacBook. If I buy an iPad Pro it will have 256GB of storage, and I will buy the Apple Keyboard and Apple Pencil. For the MacBook, 256GB of storage and 8GB of memory is a must. If it supports the Apple Pencil then I will buy the. Apple Pencil. For my device I will be using Photoshop, Illustrations, Word, photo design apps that I can make 3D renderings of devices. So what do you guys think, Will I be better off with an iPad Pro or an MacBook?

(MacBooks that I would buy is the 12 inch MacBook, or the MacBook Pro without Touch Bar 13.3 in version)
Hi, first it´s really important to consider what you need it for, then it´d be easier to give you a much precise suggestion , do remember that the  pencil is only compatible with the iPad Pro , you can find software simulating this experience on the trackpad but it´s not something I´d personally recommend, the iPad Pro makes a valid point if for some reason your job won't allow you to carry a mobile phone while on working hours, so you can receive news and feedback easily on the go , now on about the macbook , it´s much better as a general purpose device and will have available software you may be interested on most of the times
 
  • Like
Reactions: CatherineVeraGat
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.