Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
My wife has an Air and I have a pro from 2017....aside from the body style difference they both feel and look the same as far as quality build and everything.
Have you compared trackpad clicking sound and feel in silent room?
 
I've had 13" MBP's and 2020 Intel MBA and now a M1 MBA.

The build and form factor on the Air are excellent. These are the factors that I prefer about the MBA over the MBP:

1. No Touchbar - I literally detest the Touchbar. Even if you set it to show the same buttons as the function keys, there is no physical tactility and it takes more effort/looking to find the buttons. Plus feels like a total waste having it there doing nothing of use.

2. Angled keyboard - I prefer the comfort of typing on the MBA, the MBP's leading case edge is slightly raised and would dig into my wrists.

3. Smaller trackpad - nobody mentions this but I actually prefer the slightly smaller trackpad on the MBA vs the MBP. I found the Pro one was too large, my wrists would rest on it, and it generally felt more awkward to cross the width of it while dragging, etc.
 
it feels cheap but not in the tacky way, in the I can't believe I've got a laptop this quick for £999
 
Feels premium to me and I'm coming from a loaded 2020 i7 MBP 13.
I definitely prefer the wedge shape for typing. Much more comfortable over the long haul.
and NO TOUCHBAR
 
  • Like
Reactions: Never mind
Feels premium to me and I'm coming from a loaded 2020 i7 MBP 13.
I definitely prefer the wedge shape for typing. Much more comfortable over the long haul.
and NO TOUCHBAR
Make sense to me because I actually felt like downgrade in quality going from Air 2018 to Pro 2019, except the display was much better in Pro. Even speaker sound quality was much worse in Pro which sounded very tinny and lacking bass compared to Air 2018. I hope they have kept up the quality, but fear the worst especially with the display panel in Air.
 
I've had 13" MBP's and 2020 Intel MBA and now a M1 MBA.

The build and form factor on the Air are excellent. These are the factors that I prefer about the MBA over the MBP:

1. No Touchbar - I literally detest the Touchbar. Even if you set it to show the same buttons as the function keys, there is no physical tactility and it takes more effort/looking to find the buttons. Plus feels like a total waste having it there doing nothing of use.

2. Angled keyboard - I prefer the comfort of typing on the MBA, the MBP's leading case edge is slightly raised and would dig into my wrists.

3. Smaller trackpad - nobody mentions this but I actually prefer the slightly smaller trackpad on the MBA vs the MBP. I found the Pro one was too large, my wrists would rest on it, and it generally felt more awkward to cross the width of it while dragging, etc.
What MBA did you buy? The base model or the upgraded model?
 
awesome! I ordered it a few min ago. Its kinda unnecessary for me to upgrade since I have an 18 MBP 13" but with the black friday target gift card deals and resale value on my pro, I'll end up with a new computer and extra cash in hand at the end of the day so it was silly not to upgrade

You won’t be disappointed, the MacBook Airs are still premium feeling laptops, with the usual high quality Apple build and high quality materials. You’re really losing nothing in build quality or functionality with the new M1 systems. The Air and 13” Pro are incredibly similar.

I like the Air because I hate the bloody Touch Bar, much prefer a row of actual function keys.

I like the taper at the front, it’s actually more comfortable when you’re typing, sitting at a desk, the edge doesn’t dig into your wrists - of course, that will vary person to person, depending on how you hold your wrists when typing and so on.

And with the new M1, I like that it’s fan less, I’m really looking forward to that aspect.

And call me an idiot if you like, I’m a sucker for the design of the Air, it’s a nice piece of engineering, even when it’s sitting closed on a desk.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kazmac
Could you elaborate what exactly makes it feel cheap then? Especially compared to MBP 13.3"?
I meant it feels cheap as in its a fantastic laptop for the money, not cheap as in build quality. it feels just as good as my 2015 MBP in fact its easier to type on, better screen etc.
 
I just didn’t want the extra BULK on the pro when it’s not needed !!
Macbook Pro: Weight: 3.0 pounds (1.4 kg)
Macbook Air: Weight: 2.8 pounds (1.29 kg
0.11000000526Kg = 3.880135999994885oz = 110.00000526g

More weight difference than I thought; both Macbook weights combined are less weight than one of my 17.3" MSI laptops. :)
 
I've had 13" MBP's and 2020 Intel MBA and now a M1 MBA.

The build and form factor on the Air are excellent. These are the factors that I prefer about the MBA over the MBP:

1. No Touchbar - I literally detest the Touchbar. Even if you set it to show the same buttons as the function keys, there is no physical tactility and it takes more effort/looking to find the buttons. Plus feels like a total waste having it there doing nothing of use.

2. Angled keyboard - I prefer the comfort of typing on the MBA, the MBP's leading case edge is slightly raised and would dig into my wrists.

3. Smaller trackpad - nobody mentions this but I actually prefer the slightly smaller trackpad on the MBA vs the MBP. I found the Pro one was too large, my wrists would rest on it, and it generally felt more awkward to cross the width of it while dragging, etc.

Me too. Same sequence. 2011/2014 MBA > 2017 MBP > 2020 Intel MBA > 2020 M1 MBA.
 
Yeah, I wish it was a bit lighter. I'm coming from a 12" MacBook which weighs 2.03 pounds (0.92 kg)

Holding out hope they do a 12" M1 next year.
The Macbook Pro M1 13" is a really solid heavy piece of art, truly impressive in use.

I don't think I'd enjoy the weight increase of a 16" Macbook Pro M1, it would become a burden to carry - I'm disabled and it's tough to carry weight for me now.

I was thinking of upgrading to the 16" M1 when it came out, but unless I keep this 13" M1 around for mobile use I think I'll stick with the single Macbook Pro M1 13" :)
 
Coming from 2018 pro, looking to upgrade to either an Air or pro m1. Everything I've read, the air will be fine for my needs. Im no power user. But in the past it felt like a cheaper computer. Is it comparable now.. like the screen / keyboard / trackpad?

Tried to check them out in person but that seems impossible these days and want to order one. I just don't want it to end up being a downgrade.
Well, it is light ..lol.. j/k

Apple makes the best trackpads,.... that is, workng trackpads which never fail, or stick, Now the MBA is Retina, i don't think screen would matter that much anymore, as it did before.

EVeryone was wasiting for Retina, and we got it, So resolution kinda makes it unimportant. You know the resolution is gonna be better, so the question would be size of screen.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.