Here's what I did to day, in case there's something useful for others in this anecdote.
I moved a copy of my personal Dropbox to iCloud Drive, about 80 GB. It took 12 or so hours to sync up, but got done with no errors or lost files. After some reorganizing, all workflows were back to normal. This was to take care of multi-device access to personal files.
I decided to keep
Maestral running in a no-GUI mode (just the daemon) to keep selective sync running for those few shared, important folders still left in Dropbox. Those are folders produced by others, I've got to "listen" to changes to them every now and then. But by the end of my billing period, those will fit inside my Free plan, one way or another.
Comparing the footprints, Maestral is about 10x more effective in its RAM consumption, yet gets the basic job of "selective Dropbox sync" done. I don't mind keeping it running.
And then I cancelled my Dropbox paid plan, attached with an opinion directed to those who decide about the backlog prioritization of Dropbox.app for Mac. Maybe a +1 helps get the update out of the door before the end of H1/22 at least a few minutes faster.
To be clear, Dropbox support chat was very understanding and helpful in doing this cancellation for me. The support rep collected the feedback and
offered to send it to product management / developers, without asking. I got a vibe that Dropbox people had read the tweet from their CEO and are now in a bit of a scramble. That's a welcome reaction.
First observations:
- As far as I can tell, iCloud Drive is just as good (or bad) at keeping files in sync quickly.
- Getting a share link to a file requires more clicks in iCloud Drive than in Dropbox, but it works.
- Sharing a folder requires the recipient to have an AppleID and their own iCloud Drive. That's silly and a less-than-ideal workflow, but not a show-stopper for me. If it must be shared, I'll zip it and share it as a file. I don't know what's the rational thinking behind this. "Let's market this by limiting the access to folders but not files" doesn't sound like a winning plan from Apple's part.
Overall, a downgrade in sharing abilities, but an upgrade in system responsiveness. I actually needed that last GB of RAM that Dropbox.app always took!