Become a MacRumors Supporter for $25/year with no ads, private forums, and more!

DVD or CD Sharing Setup Update for Mac/PC

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
51,584
13,215

liberty4all

Guest
Jan 7, 2007
305
0
How to enable it for other Macs/PCs?!

This would be a lot more practical if it was usable for other Macs/PCs besides just the Air... Seems like wasted potential just for one device -- where's the backwards compatibility?!
 
Comment

Doctor Q

Administrator
Staff member
Sep 19, 2002
38,449
4,963
Los Angeles
Is there a technical reason that sharing a remote optical drive couldn't be made available for all Mac models?

Is there a business reason for Apple not to allow it?
 
Comment

awmazz

macrumors 65816
Jul 4, 2007
1,100
0
There is a DVD/CD sharing option in the OSX sharing preferences (at least in 10.5.2, I never noticed it before).

I just tested it and I can read the CD in my Mac Mini's optical drive on my Mac Pro.

PS. There is no eject control from the networked computer, it appears it has to be done by the computer which owns the drive.

Edit: Or do you guys mean sharing a stand-alone drive? I imagine it could just be connected to one Mac on a network and accessed via that way by other Macs.
 
Comment

Art Vandelay

macrumors newbie
Jan 11, 2003
14
0
Is there a technical reason that sharing a remote optical drive couldn't be made available for all Mac models?

You've always been able to share optical discs via file sharing. This just provides a simpler way via Bonjour.
 
Comment

ppc_michael

Guest
Apr 26, 2005
1,498
2
Los Angeles, CA
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPod; U; CPU like Mac OS X; en) AppleWebKit/420.1 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/3.0 Mobile/4A102 Safari/419.3)

Why is this listed as working with 10.4 if it's only available for MacBook Air (10.5)?
 
Comment

Art Vandelay

macrumors newbie
Jan 11, 2003
14
0
You don't install it on the Air. You install it on the computer that has the optical drive you want to share.
 
Comment

bstreiff

macrumors regular
Feb 14, 2008
215
1
Austin, TX, USA
There is a DVD/CD sharing option in the OSX sharing preferences (at least in 10.5.2, I never noticed it before).

I just tested it and I can read the CD in my Mac Mini's optical drive on my Mac Pro.

How? I've got a CD in my Mac Mini with DVD/CD Sharing enabled, but I don't see how to access it through Remote Disc from my MacBook-- I'm pretty sure the non-Airs cannot do Remote Disc.
 
Comment

awmazz

macrumors 65816
Jul 4, 2007
1,100
0
How? I've got a CD in my Mac Mini with DVD/CD Sharing enabled, but I don't see how to access it through Remote Disc from my MacBook-- I'm pretty sure the non-Airs cannot do Remote Disc.

I've since found DVD/CD sharing doesn't work (for me at least) unless File Sharing is also active (I assume to access the files on the disc in the optical drive just like any other shared hard drive on the hosting Mac).

No connection appears to be possible with just DVD/CD sharing active, but File Sharing inactive.

So it's just a standard 'connect to server' routine.
 
Comment

bstreiff

macrumors regular
Feb 14, 2008
215
1
Austin, TX, USA
I've since found DVD/CD sharing doesn't work (for me at least) unless File Sharing is also active (I assume to access the files on the disc in the optical drive just like any other shared hard drive on the hosting Mac).

No connection appears to be possible with just DVD/CD sharing active, but File Sharing inactive.

So it's just a standard 'connect to server' routine.

That's not Remote Disc; that's just plain File Sharing. (It works regardless of whether DVD/CD sharing is on or off.) File Sharing just shares out every volume on the machine, whether they be internal hard drive partitions, inserted discs, or attached Firewire/USB disks.
 
Comment

awmazz

macrumors 65816
Jul 4, 2007
1,100
0
That's not Remote Disc; that's just plain File Sharing. (It works regardless of whether DVD/CD sharing is on or off.)

That's what I figure too, so I can't figure out why DVD/CD Sharing has its own option when it doesn't work on it's own (at least for me) without File Sharing being enabled too.

If it's just part of File Sharing and needs FS enabled to even work, why is it a separate option?
 
Comment

bstreiff

macrumors regular
Feb 14, 2008
215
1
Austin, TX, USA
Well, I'd imagine that Remote Disc works differently; based on my playing around with the protocol (it's not too difficult, just a HTTP transport), you can actually get the entire filesystem from it; I was able to grab the entire ISO9660 image for a disc that I was playing with (some motherboard driver CD, it was the first thing in my drawer.) This is different from the way File Sharing works (it abstracts away the underlying filesystem).

The driver functionality, however, seems to be restricted to the Air-- reading documentation on it, 'Remote Disc' gets its own device entry in Finder, etc. I'm just wondering if Apple will add it to OS X in general, as it seems like it could be very useful, especially if, for instance, it eventually offers things like being able to burn discs (so that not every machine needs to have a DVD burner to burn a DVD).
 
Comment

J-mizzle

macrumors newbie
Nov 21, 2007
14
2
I'm just wondering if Apple will add it to OS X in general, as it seems like it could be very useful, especially if, for instance, it eventually offers things like being able to burn discs (so that not every machine needs to have a DVD burner to burn a DVD).

word. That would come in awful handy... but how would that work? Would it use up some of your processing power, when you could just copy the files over to the other machine and tell it to burn on its own? I mean, I'm all for the lazy solution and everything, but my mini is slow enough as it is! Maybe when i get that new iMac it won't be a problem, though...
 
Comment
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.