Nice break down. Watch is a great device, but absolutely redundant! Not interested in buying one.
You may not want one, but you don't get to claim it is 'absolutely redundant.' Such a charge would imply that no one could possibly find any use for one.
My wife already has hers and I saw her Apple Pay twice with it. As a woman she would normally have to fish in her purse for her phone, unlock it, find the app, do Apple Pay.
She just double tapped the button, held her wrist by the scanner and boom, done.
That's not redundant, that was actual functionality, something she used it for.
She's liking the health stuff which you can't do with just the watch alone, I think I'm going to like that too. In fact her work place has some sponsored walk thing going on next week based on steps. If she didn't have the Apple Watch she'd have had to buy or borrow some pedometer of some kind to participate.
So great that YOU don't want one, but it is inaccurate to claim it is redundant in general.
For me I travel a lot so I'm going to be looking forward to time zone syncs, boarding passes, flight delay information, hotel check ins, weather and other travel related applications.
I've honestly never seen a product launch where so many people take to the Internet to bash something, often times before ever using one, seeing one, and many people were doing this even before reviews.
You don't want it, don't buy it, I'm not sure it needs any further comment.
I don't seek out a Ducati forum to let them know I'm not into bikes. I don't troll WWF forums to tell them wrestling is silly. I don't go on Amazon.com and post on products I'm not going to buy, explaining why.
Just seems odd.