Editing HD straight from SD cards?

mwpierce

macrumors newbie
Original poster
May 12, 2013
2
0
Hello,

I have a question about editing HD video using Adobe Premiere and footage from a class 10 SD card (Sandisk Extreme). My editing machine is a 24" imac with dual core 3.06Ghz pentium, 12 GB RAM, 500 GB internal HD and 2TB external drive connected via ilink 800.

I'm looking for a way to inexpensively speed up my editing process and am wondering if I can edit directly from my SD cards by plugging one into the SD slot and connecting the other through an SD reader of some sort (I'd like iLink but I can't find one). Currently I dump my cards to my external drive and edit from there (no problems with that, I'm just trying to avoid a step).

Does anyone have experience reading footage and editing directly from SD cards or do you think that'll just be too slow and I should continue with my current setup?

Thanks for your help.
 

Nov 28, 2010
22,684
27
located
The advantage of copying the footage to another external Firewire 800 HDD (i.Link is Sony's name for Firewire, especially that 4-pin Firewire 400 port found on DV cameras) is that you can edit faster and access the data faster and that you can create backups faster.
What if the random access to the SD cards during editing diminishes their lives and you haven't created any backups yet?
 

kohlson

macrumors 68020
Apr 23, 2010
2,047
553
There are perhaps two bottlenecks with your proposed SD solution. An SD card, give or take, is 5-10x slower than a disk drive. Cards vary significantly in speed (R/W) but are always much slower than a disk. The other bottleneck is the I/O to the SD card. If this is the direct slot on the side of a Mac, this is probably not a big deal, but if USB or FW, that adds another layer of the slows. Also, there is some thinking that these cards aren't that durable when used as a drive.
 

mwpierce

macrumors newbie
Original poster
May 12, 2013
2
0
The advantage of copying the footage to another external Firewire 800 HDD (i.Link is Sony's name for Firewire, especially that 4-pin Firewire 400 port found on DV cameras) is that you can edit faster and access the data faster and that you can create backups faster.
What if the random access to the SD cards during editing diminishes their lives and you haven't created any backups yet?
That is an excellent point - I run the risk of shortening the life of my SD cards. Thanks for that feedback!

Matt

----------

There are perhaps two bottlenecks with your proposed SD solution. An SD card, give or take, is 5-10x slower than a disk drive. Cards vary significantly in speed (R/W) but are always much slower than a disk. The other bottleneck is the I/O to the SD card. If this is the direct slot on the side of a Mac, this is probably not a big deal, but if USB or FW, that adds another layer of the slows. Also, there is some thinking that these cards aren't that durable when used as a drive.
More excellent feedback! I think I'll stick with disk drives.

Matt
 

mBox

macrumors 68020
Jun 26, 2002
2,273
35
That would be a scary ride editing right off any SD card.
Remember those things are made for writing mostly.
Reading and Writing not so safe.
Remember, data corrupts at any given time.