I never had a TV tuner as a Windows user over the years so I don't have a frame a reference, but I absolutely love my eyetv 250 plus and the eyetv3 software. Not only is watching live TV on my mac great, but the ability to add a "second DVR" with editing capabilities totally kicks butt. I know there are TV tuners for the PC by ATI and others, but I can't imagine they can touch this combo. Waaay cool and a breeze to setup!