Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
First of all, you shouldn't compare Mac Pro to a regular desktop as it's a workstation. However, Dell offers in-home service even for regular desktops. For workstations, they offer pretty much anything you want.

I know and I completely agree with you. But, the OP (and many others with this question) compare it to a desktop. I'm only trying to offer a suggestion as to how one can justify the MP price when 'only' a desktop is required.

But, I did not know that Dell offers in-home service. Is that free? Seems like a great deal. I've had experience with HP service second-hand and it wasn't good. But that was with a laptop so maybe they have different policies than a desktop.
 
But, I did not know that Dell offers in-home service. Is that free? Seems like a great deal. I've had experience with HP service second-hand and it wasn't good. But that was with a laptop so maybe they have different policies than a desktop.

Looks like it's free as even the basic warranty includes in-home service.

http://www.dell.com/content/topics/segtopic.aspx/services/learn_more?c=us&cs=19&l=en&s=dhs

I don't have any experience with that though, Dell doesn't offer it in Finland. It says that the technician may be from a 3rd party thus the quality of service may vary. It sounds nice though
 
Looks like it's free as even the basic warranty includes in-home service.

http://www.dell.com/content/topics/segtopic.aspx/services/learn_more?c=us&cs=19&l=en&s=dhs

I don't have any experience with that though, Dell doesn't offer it in Finland. It says that the technician may be from a 3rd party thus the quality of service may vary. It sounds nice though
The techs are always 3rd party, as HP, Dell, and most others have all gone to contracted service providers (Apple's the only exception I can think of for Intel based systems).
 
Yes Dell has in home service - but how trained are their service techs? I and several friends have had techs who knew very little - one tech was going to over write the good drive on my Raid zero setup - second drive was bad. I had to have a temper tantrum for him to stop and then I made him call to Dell to verify I was right = and I was! He left mad but I had my data. Darlene
 
Yes Dell has in home service - but how trained are their service techs? I and several friends have had techs who knew very little - one tech was going to over write the good drive on my Raid zero setup - second drive was bad. I had to have a temper tantrum for him to stop and then I made him call to Dell to verify I was right = and I was! He left mad but I had my data. Darlene

Pretty sure that you meant RAID 1, not 0.
If it had been a RAID 0, all your data would have been lost in case of a drive failure.

Anyway, who has experience with the Apple technicians that come to visit you?
I've heard some really bad things about them as well (which is why I always take my machines to my local AASP).
 
Yes Dell has in home service - but how trained are their service techs? I and several friends have had techs who knew very little - one tech was going to over write the good drive on my Raid zero setup - second drive was bad. I had to have a temper tantrum for him to stop and then I made him call to Dell to verify I was right = and I was! He left mad but I had my data. Darlene
It can vary widely. Some are excellent, others, well... not so much. Your location has a lot to do with it, as does the service provider, and the problem. Once you put in a call, the service provider contacts their techs, who agree/disagree to take the job based on the problem, and the payment amount.

For the low paying (less desirable stuff), the best techs tend to avoid it, as the provider company (who Dell, HP,... hires for the calls), tends to rip them off.

Location comes into this, as they're usually stuck paying their own fuel,... (tend not to get any reimbursement for travel expenses, even if its outside their normal service range).

It gets complicated, but if you're curious, look up a company called Barrister Global Services (example). They tend to make their real profits off the backs of their techs due to all the methods they've in place to rip them off. :eek: :( :mad:
 
From the responses, I still am unclear if the entry level MP is worth the additional 1000+ dollars.

Thanks

I think think you need to accept that your question is very subjective and can only be answered by you. The Mac Pro, component for component, can seem expensive in comparison to another manufacturers PC (although when you take into account the Xeon processors, a bit less so). But it is a Mac, and only one company makes Mac, so there is no choice or comparison (excluding Hackintoshes). For some this makes perfect sense and there is no question to be asked. For others it just does not. If you are still unclear if the entry level MP is worth the extra money, then I would suggest you are in the latter category and you should spend your money on the Windows PC with the better spec.
 
why don't you get the pleasure of both worlds?
Get a macbook/pro/mini and build a desktop(it's pretty easy) or a prebuilt with windows.

I think I may go this route, but will wait for the MBP to refresh.
I ordered an HP 470f and Dell u2311h monitor.

Dell dropped their price by 10 dollars and I emailed them and said I just ordered it and they will not adjust the price. They said I had to ship it back and pay for the shipping and may incur a 15% restock fee. I have owned HP before and never had any issues like this.
 
If you use windows then go for the PC. But if your like me and can't stand windows and like OSX then go for the Mac Pro. Both machines can be upgraded. The Mac will hold its price more than the PC....just look on ebay.

I was deciding between a £2200 Mac Pro or £1400 PC. The PC will loose most its value in 2-3 years but the Mac Pro's sell for 50 - 60% of the original price when 3-4 years old. So over time Mac Pros are cheaper than PC's.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.