I bought my case in the Apple Store 1/3/16 and didn't notice anything wrong with it at the time when I purchased it but did notice a couple issues on others at the store. The problem is the corner by the camera cutout has a with spot like the finish is missing or wore off not sure what's going on I did notice the cutout around the mute switch is rough as well. I talked evutec they suggested I return it to the Apple Store it is better than a hour drive so I wondered if it is just a defective case as they said or if it is the finish actually going to wear off over time the case has not been dropped or abused I baby my phone I didn't know if it could happen from carrying in jeans pocket for just as few days not what I consider a good case for $50. I tried to show it In the picture but is way more obvious in person than the picture