Toggle sidebar Toggle sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Expensive Apple RAM - Is it worth it?

cmcbridejr

cmcbridejr

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Why is adding extra RAM on Apple's BTO options so expensive?

Apple says that they use "special thermal pasting blah blah blah to reduce heat in the RAM so that the computer runs cooler and uses the fan less".

Is this true or just a bunch of marketing hype?

Kingston memory from Amazon seems to be so much less than what Apple wants. Is it just as good?
 
cmcbridejr said:
Why is adding extra RAM on Apple's BTO options so expensive?

Apple says that they use "special thermal pasting blah blah blah to reduce heat in the RAM so that the computer runs cooler and uses the fan less".

Is this true or just a bunch of marketing hype?

Kingston memory from Amazon seems to be so much less than what Apple wants. Is it just as good?
Click to expand...

apple doesn't even produce RAM... get one from newegg.com half to quarter the price with just as good quality. 😀
 
Memory from other retailers, such as Crucial, are on par with "Apple" ram. Some even guarantee compatibility with Apple products, so you don't need to worry about that issue. Cheers.
 
Never ever buy the RAM from Apple. Complete and total rip off. You are getting something for that premium: installation and coverage under Apple's warranty. Are those things worth a 100%-300% premium? For most its no.
 
I got mine from Crucial and it works fine, plus it was less than half the Apple price.

Caution - Apple claim your AppleCare will be invalidated by using 3rd Party RAM, so keep the old RAM to quickly put back in incase of an AppleCare claim 🙂
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
Not too many buy Apple ram. Personally I always use Crucial, I know it's not the cheapest around but I've never had any ram related problems .. 🙂
 
cmcbridejr said:
http://www.amazon.com/Kingston-Memory-DIMM-200-pin-unbuffered/dp/B000K1KTNW/ref=pd_sim_e_title_1
If so, will I notice a major difference from 2 GB versus 4 GB?
Mind you, I have been using an iMac G5 with 2 GB RAM for years, mainly with audio recording and Final Cut Pro projects.
Click to expand...

That is the correct RAM for Core2Duo Macs. (you don't say what model machine you have)

Keep in mind you are buying from ANTOnline, not Amazon. I have no experience with ANTOnline.

http://www.resellerratings.com/store/Atlanta_Network_Technologies

One dealer I can recommend in the USA is Data Memory Systems $98 with a free shipping option and great support.

How much speed up you see depends a lot on what you are doing, but in general, 4 GB for digital audio and digital video is recommended.
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
tekilla said:
I got mine from Crucial and it works fine, plus it was less than half the Apple price.

Caution - Apple claim your AppleCare will be invalidated by using 3rd Party RAM, so keep the old RAM to quickly put back in incase of an AppleCare claim 🙂
Click to expand...

I thought that upgrading ram in an iMac was OK. i thought it was the only user upgradeable part that is still covered by applecare
 
THird party memory does not void Applecare (but of course Apple does not warranty the new memory).

What the other poster may be referring to is that there have been incidents where lazy or incompetent service techs will take a machine in that has, say, a logic board problem, spot the third party RAM, and simply send the machine back saying "it's your RAM, it's bad" without working on the machine.

To short circuit that argument, some recommend to keep your Apple RAM in a drawer, and reinstall it before sending your machine for warranty service.
 
Sorry guys - you might want to double check that.

I spoke to an Apple rep about buying a MacBook Pro the other day and they said that if you change the memory yourself, that buy opening the case, you're voiding your AppleCare.
 
tekilla said:
Sorry guys - you might want to double check that.

I spoke to an Apple rep about buying a Mac Book Pro the other day and they said that if you change the memory yourself, that buy opening the case, you're voiding your Apple Care.
Click to expand...

Speaking as an owner of multiple Macs, all with 3rd party RAM inside of them...no apple service tech has told me that my AppleCare is void. I have been suggested to replace the 3rd party RAM with original Apple RAM when taking my machines in for service by a tech.

🙂These are user serviceable parts, except for those with the Mac Mini (which takes some care to replace the RAM).

There is no possible way to tell if the RAM has been replaced with 3rd party and then put back again, at least to the naked eye (AFAIK).

I wouldn't be too paranoid about installing 3rd party RAM...just make sure it is reputable. I use OWC, as many do here on Mac Rumors. Kingston, Corsair, and Crucial are also good RAM dealers/makers as well. 🙄
 
In which case, maybe that was just a cheeky way of scaring me into only using their $$$ memory !

They did definetly say that by opening the case to install the memory, you'd be voiding your AppleCare, but if there's no way to tell... what the hell 🙂
 
cmcbridejr said:
Thank you all for the quick replies.

I figured it was all fancy marketing by the great hype machine.

Anyone currently using this RAM:

http://www.amazon.com/Kingston-Memory-DIMM-200-pin-unbuffered/dp/B000K1KTNW/ref=pd_sim_e_title_1

If so, will I notice a major difference from 2 GB versus 4 GB?

Mind you, I have been using an iMac G5 with 2 GB RAM for years, mainly with audio recording and Final Cut Pro projects.

Thanks again.
Click to expand...

dont buy ram from amazon, go to newegg.com and get it there. They usually have the cheapest prices and fastest shipping.
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
I've upgraded 3 of our 4 Macs here with more RAM from OWC and never had a problem. It just seems crazy to me to buy it from :apple: at their prices when you can do it yourself. (And if I can do it, then anyone can!)
 
It's a little something for the distribution chain

Margins on some of the main kit must be pretty slim - I think Apple allows the distribution chain to get a little icing on their cake this way. Smart purchasers will go elsewhere, those with more money than sense can help subsidise the channel.
 
arkitect said:
Marketing hype.
Click to expand...

Like the rest of the machine.

I only think it makes sense if you're buying for business or fairly critical personal use for the smooth(est under the circumstances, given the crappiness of Applecare) support for the whole system.

Which is why I always buy Apple RAM.
 
There's no such thing as "Apple RAM". In all the Macs I've owned, it has always been "Samsung" RAM. Besides, whenever I've bought 3rd party RAM I've decided to go with Crucial.
 
tekilla said:
Sorry guys - you might want to double check that.

I spoke to an Apple rep about buying a MacBook Pro the other day and they said that if you change the memory yourself, that buy opening the case, you're voiding your AppleCare.
Click to expand...

Then why, pray tell, do they provide a hatch on the bottom of the machine for accessing the memory, and instructions in the user manual for DIY memory installation...?

http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=303491
 
CanadaRAM said:
Then why, pray tell, do they provide a hatch on the bottom of the machine for accessing the memory, and instructions in the user manual for DIY memory installation...?

http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=303491
Click to expand...

They'd have a pretty tough time denying coverage. Here are the Terms and Conditions

Obviously they don't cover 3d party memory. And they might be able to deny coverage if the 3d party memory caused the problem (which is pretty hard to prove).

But this provision seems to mean that if you modify your computer by adding memory per apple instructions (like those posted), then you're still covered:

b. Limitations. The Plan does not cover:
. . .
(iii) Your use of or modification to the Covered Equipment, the Mac OS, iPod Software, Apple TV Software or Consumer Software in a manner for which the Covered Equipment or software is not intended to be used or modified;
Click to expand...

Apple would have a pretty difficult time arguing that a MacBook was not "intended to be modified" by the addition of memory per the instructions provided by Apple.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back