ext hdd mounting issue

Hi guys,
really don't know what else can or where else to ask about this,

I'm using the macbook pro retina with mavericks.
bought a seagate 4tb desktop hdd with vantec usb 3.0 enclosure
these two combination will not mount on my mbp
it would not mount and is the hdd does not appear in my disk utility as well.
tried going to terminal with the command diskutil list and the hdd is no where to be found as well.

however, the same combination when plugged to windows is mounted.

so far, i've tried :
- mount the disc to windows, format it to gpt nfts = can't mount
- mount the disc to windows, format it to gpt exfat = can't mount
- mount the disc to windows, format it to gpt hfs using paragon hard disk manager = can't mount too.

i took apart and plug the hdd to my old western digital enclosure which is connected with usb 2.0, the disc is mounted, saw it in disc utility but only 1.8TB.

i'm quite sure when i bought the hdd and enclosure, both said it is compatible with the mac.
i'm not sure what is wrong....is it the cable...or...?
because i also tried using a usb 2.0 cable to connect them and still it won't work.

 

hi,
yeah..i've tried formatting them to apple hfs and still unmountable.
but with the same said formatting, when enclosed with a wd case, it's mountable and read-writable.

also, i tried the same thing with my friend's imac that's still running mountain lion. also can't be mounted and doesn't appear on disk utility.

if the box of the enclosure doesn't say that it's compatible with mac, then i'm pretty sure it's the enclosure problem but here, the box clearly writes that it's mac compatible : /

the whole hdd works fine with windows though.