Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Jacanidae

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Sep 9, 2015
2
0
I have a WD elements eternal hard drive. My macbook pro (late 2012) has recently begun having issues reading it, takes about 5 minutes for it to pop up in Finder. When I plug my hard drive into the PC boot camp side of my computer I don't have any issues with it being read (less than a minute). The hard drive was reading perfectly fine until a month ago, and I have no idea why it's not reading quickly anymore. Help?
 
I have a WD elements eternal hard drive. My macbook pro (late 2012) has recently begun having issues reading it, takes about 5 minutes for it to pop up in Finder. When I plug my hard drive into the PC boot camp side of my computer I don't have any issues with it being read (less than a minute). The hard drive was reading perfectly fine until a month ago, and I have no idea why it's not reading quickly anymore. Help?

I'd recommend going back into Bootcamp and downloading HD Tune Pro. From there, click 'Health', and select your external HDD from the drop-down list. If at the bottom-left, the health shows as anything other than 'OK', the hard-drive is failing.

If that's OK, please can you confirm which format the disk is in (FAT32, exFAT?) If it's in NTFS, did you download an NTFS driver for OS X (and if so, which one was it please?)
 
I'd recommend going back into Bootcamp and downloading HD Tune Pro. From there, click 'Health', and select your external HDD from the drop-down list. If at the bottom-left, the health shows as anything other than 'OK', the hard-drive is failing.

If that's OK, please can you confirm which format the disk is in (FAT32, exFAT?) If it's in NTFS, did you download an NTFS driver for OS X (and if so, which one was it please?)

The format is FAT32.

Would the hard drive be failing if it works perfectly fine on the PC side? I use it on the PC side to run a MMO off of it and the game works great.

Also I ran check disk in Terminal to see if there were any issues and it was fine.
 
The format is FAT32.
Would the hard drive be failing if it works perfectly fine on the PC side? I use it on the PC side to run a MMO off of it and the game works great.

Well it'll only take 2 minutes to check so it's best to verify the worst case scenario before we look into anything else.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.