Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Eh? MacOS has almost better controller support than Windows:

Not from my experience when I've looked for controllers - particularly HOTAS/flight sticks and they often lacked native Mac support. I require a freeware driver for my wired Xbox 360 controller to work even on Catalina. This is the controller for a console that sold over 85 million units during its production run.

...every current controller of all major console manufacturers (Sony, Microsoft, Nintendo) is supported out of the box and wirelessly.

Yes, however the caveat being that haptic feedback and the adaptive triggers are not supported for the PS5 controller.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Amethyst1
I just want to be able to maximize the active window to the screen without holding a damn key down. No I don't want to full screen it to a new space. That's not what this button is meant for.
View attachment 1994096
Ummm. Click the green button? Works for me. If you do a “mouse over” you get a menu, but just click. Problem solved - you are welcome
 
  • Angry
Reactions: heinzdembowski
That’s not a ”menu bar item”, though.
No it isn't. I guess it's just down to how you function then. I'd rather have a keyboard shortcut as the majority of the time my hands are on the keyboard. I'm a keyboard shortcut type. Some people are mouse users and do everything with the mouse including menu commands (not necessarily saying that's you).

Until Apple gives you that though…Funter.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Amethyst1
Here's mine:

  • Full support for Blu-ray. Yes, it's not going to happen but I still wish that it was a full blown feature. The fact that Apple deliberately hobbled this because they wanted to push their customers into purchasing HD content from iTunes instead is disgraceful. There was room for both models.
  • Better support for game controllers. Having to check whether these devices are macOS compatible before I buy them or needing to track down freeware drivers produced by volunteers is jarring. It's a head scratcher that Apple hasn't promoted the Mac as a viable gaming platform in many years and has shown no interest in undertaking the most simplest of actions to provide the functionality at a basic level for to this happen.
  • VR headset compatibility. As above, Apple's failure in courting the industry to support macOS in this respect is disappointing. At present the HTC Vive is the only macOS compatible VR headset.
  • Native support for Internet access via USB tethering on Android smartphones. Again, this is a functionality that volunteers have provided for macOS with freeware drivers. That Apple hasn't reached out to the Open Handset Alliance to include drivers as standard is dismaying. You can't even access files on your phone via USB without downloading a driver first - and Google's AFT software isn't particularly great. It almost makes me suspect that Apple doesn't want to make things easy for people who choose not to purchase an iPhone.
  • Wider support in QuickTime for file formats. It can't play open, non-proprietary stuff like MKV's. Not without help from Perian anyway and that's been discontinued. I'm aware that VLC is available but there are situations where QT has advantages.
Blu-ray? That is still a thing. I grabbed an app years ago to use Blu-ray, but that is way retro now.
Game controllers- but everyone says you can’t game on a Mac. Must be a typo. And lordyB have to check if something works when compatibility is listed right on the box, scandalous
Android and a Mac, now there is a minority. Have you tried those android virtualizations that let you run android software? Personally, the reason to go apple is the integration so why?
QT works for me - don’t have legacy stuff hanging around. It’s pretty easy to transcode and using handbrake with video toolbox. Really quick. I will admit that I would like to see enhancements like iMovie added to QT. THATS WHY I ALSO HAVE INFUSE, admittedly I don’t use it much, but it is great even intelligently upscales
 
Ummm. Click the green button? Works for me. If you do a “mouse over” you get a menu, but just click. Problem solved - you are welcome
Problem solved?

Try doing that with additional attached displays. Every screen goes black while you get full screen on the one you simply clicked that on. How is that a solution?

@Doq wants to be able to maximize a window without holding down the OPTN key, not enter full screen.
 
For me: mere consistency. macOS used to use the 1 "kilo"byte == 1024 bytes way but Snow Leopard switched to the "correct" way. I often switch between older and newer versions of macOS (this is the PowerPC subforum, after all :)) and having Finder report the exact same file with two different sizes is annoying.
The actual problem is, of course, that the "incorrect" way was allowed to see widespread use in the first place, leading to some people being shocked that their spanking new one-terabyte drive showed up as being only 931 "giga"byte in the OS.


...which is why I keep the device I store my audiobooks on on Android 4.1.2: it exposes the microSD card as a standard mass storage device so I don't need any driver... with the obvious sideeffect of anything running on the phone needing to deal with the card being yanked from its grasp while the USB connection is alive.
That’s why I use the cloud. All my files available anywhere and on any device. No drivers required
 
I know about the keyboard shortcut. Make a menu bar item anyways. I don't always want to move my hands off the mouse to view a hidden file.
I guess I just operate differently. I usually have my left thumb resting on the CMD key with my right hand on the mouse. Much easier for me to simply move my right hand over and back. But everyone is different. I made a link to Funter above if you didn't see it.
 
The only thing I want from Apple is to bring back tasty and smooth UI. The scalling is seriously wrong. I can use a decade old Windows device and it runs like butter no matter what monitor I connect to it. You can't even have a fluid UI with Apple's latest computers if you don't use ideal combination of their devices and monitors. It's embarrassing.
 
Better support for external drives. First, can the OS dynamically pre-eject external disks until they're needed by some process? Maybe if they haven't been read from or written to after some period of time? I might be dreaming here.

Also, when I do a Spotlight search, you don't need to wait for my external hard drives to fully spin up before you start giving me results, especially if that external drive is just a Time Machine backup.
 
Better support for external drives. First, can the OS dynamically pre-eject external disks until they're needed by some process? Maybe if they haven't been read from or written to after some period of time? I might be dreaming here.

Also, when I do a Spotlight search, you don't need to wait for my external hard drives to fully spin up before you start giving me results, especially if that external drive is just a Time Machine backup.
I don't mean to sound pedantic, but couldn't you just exclude your external drives from Spotlight?

Unless you're wanting them to be indexed?
 
I thought of another one. This one is huge. Let me command-tab between windows of the same app. If I have four Chrome windows open, or two Word windows, put them in the command-tab row. I know you can switch to command-~ for same-app windows, but that's an extra cognitive hop. This is something Windows has had over macOS since the dawn of time.

May as well make it optional for people who like the current arrangement.
 
I don't mean to sound pedantic, but couldn't you just exclude your external drives from Spotlight?

Unless you're wanting them to be indexed?
Sure, I suppose I could mind my Spotlight settings to ensure any new external drives are excluded, but we're talking about new feature requests here aren't we?
 
Sure, I suppose I could mind my Spotlight settings to ensure any new external drives are excluded, but we're talking about new feature requests here aren't we?
Yes, I just presumed that it's new feature requests for things that either aren't there (in some form) already or can't be changed because they are baked in.
 
Popup windows and minimize in place. Both, OS9 features I've been waiting for Apple to bring back since 2002. We got spring-loaded folders back and labels back, but not those two features.

Two of the few things about OS9 I miss. Popup windows made it very easy to keep folders open without having them take up all your screen space while still being able to move files around. Minimize in place is only possible with third party apps such as Deskovery.

EDIT: Oh, and transparent windows with the ability to adjust the alpha level would be nice. The ability to see your desktop through your browser window or Finder windows. There's an old browser that does this but it's circa 2002-2003 tech.
Thank you! This was the first thing I thought of when I saw this thread. I want WindowShade back! Please!
 
Not from my experience when I've looked for controllers - particularly HOTAS/flight sticks and they often lacked native Mac support.
Have you tried? My Saitek X52 Pro is better supported under macOS in X-Plane, War Thunder, and Elite Dangerous (while the Mac version still existed) than under Windows: while there without specific drivers only the most basic functions and a few buttons work, every single control element works under macOS without any additional software. The only thing not properly supported under macOS is the LC display.

I require a freeware driver for my wired Xbox 360 controller to work even on Catalina. This is the controller for a console that sold over 85 million units during its production run.
…and one which hasn't been produced or sold for half a decade. Pretty much every Xbox controller released after that, save for the first version of the Xbox One controller with its weird propietary wireless protocol, work without any additional driver under macOS.

And even while it still was relevant, was the Xbox 360 controller pretty much the only controller requiring specific drivers. The vast majority of other gamepads from other manufacturers did not.

Yes, however the caveat being that haptic feedback and the adaptive triggers are not supported for the PS5 controller.
You can still use it in every game using macOS's built-in controller support. Under Windows, there is only an extremely small number of games which specifically have been written to support the DualSense 5.
 
Last edited:
So, in all the years I've been using Mac OS X/OS X/macOS, there are a couple of features I'd like to see (re-)added which, annoyingly, have not (yet) been implemented or have been removed but are available on other operating systems *cough, cough*. These are, in no particular order:
  • Rename macOS back to Mac OS X. (OK, OK, this feature isn't available on other OSes but you get the point.)
  • Make all "hard-coded" font types and sizes adjustable. Menu bar, I'm looking at you!
  • Support themes to allow giving the UI a comprehensive new look.
  • Combine several monitors into one big virtual monitor à la AMD Eyefinity for e.g. the IBM Bertha and other tiled displays.
  • Add full support for MST so DisplayPort/USB-C monitors can be daisy-chained.
  • Handle non-integer UI scaling in a more flexible way.
  • Add UI scaling beyond 200% for >220ppi monitors.
  • Provide a powerful package manager for handling (un-)installation of applications.
  • Provide a straightforward way to create a bootable macOS USB installer without having to resort to createinstallmedia on another Mac.
  • Allow writing to NTFS partitions.
  • Return to the 1 "KB" == 1024 bytes etc. convention.
  • Improve Disk Utility's UI.
  • Readd support for 32-bit applications.
  • Enable Rosetta 2 to run PowerPC applications on ARM Macs.

So, what are the features you would like to see (re-)added? :)
The last one is not going to happen but would be nice. Not even sure how many PowerPC applications are still being maintained. Haven't we moved on from them?
 
The thread is a wishlist for macOS on Arm CPUs [...]
I never said or implied it was just for ARM.

Uhm…this entire thread is posted in the PowerPC Mac section of MacRumors.
Yeah, but why? [...]
Honest answer: I'm interested in hearing what established members of the PowerPC subforum, who might have been using macOS, i.e. Mac OS X, for a very long time, would like to see in it. However, everyone is of course welcome to contribute. :)

The last one is not going to happen but would be nice.
That one was tongue-in-cheek. ;)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: TheShortTimer
Honest answer: I'm interested in hearing what established members of the PowerPC subforum, who might have been using macOS, i.e. Mac OS X, for a very long time, would like to see in it. However, everyone is of course welcome to contribute. :)
Fair enough.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Amethyst1
It’s never going to be Mac OS X again as we’re at macOS XII now… the rest I can agree on.
I’d personally add
- better continuity between iOS and macOS apps (same design and features for both)
- automations like on iOS devices (time/location/Wi-Fi/… based automations)
- reworked launcher
- better widgets
- individual scaling/size for each app and window within an app (kinda like individual text size in iOS)
- a PiP player like in iOS (with skip forward / backward buttons)
- desktop(s) arrangement options somewhat like workspace options in FCPX
- a proper wallpaper editor
- nativ and overhauled Apple Music app
- multi window support for apps like FCPX, Settings, GarageBand, Music and others, all basically
- more than 3 fingerprints with Touch ID enabled devices…
- a freaking Snow release focused on stability and bug fixes!!!!!!!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Amethyst1
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.