Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

bkribbs

macrumors 65816
Original poster
Jan 15, 2012
1,178
0
So clearly 2012 rMBP users have a problem with automatic switching graphics on Yosemite. Do we know which kexts are necessary for this and maybe we could pull them from mavericks and install them until Apple fixes this themselves? Freezing constantly here, really NOT cool.
 

nickbarbs

macrumors regular
Nov 26, 2009
202
57
I was constantly freezing untill I turned off SMCFancontrol and gfxcardstatus ( Dont load them programs).

Hope this is helpful.
 

Brian Y

macrumors 68040
Oct 21, 2012
3,776
1,064
My 2012 is being replaced because of this. It's gotten to the point where my machine just freezes and cuts out at least twice per day, which makes it pretty much unusable.

I don't use gfxcardstatus or SMCfancontrol, and it happens on a clean install of Yosemite.

Out of interest, I see you also have the 2.7GHz model. Maybe it's just that CPU that's causing issues? Does anyone with the 2.3 or 2.6GHz machines have the same problem?
 

cjmillsnun

macrumors 68020
Aug 28, 2009
2,399
48
My 2012 is being replaced because of this. It's gotten to the point where my machine just freezes and cuts out at least twice per day, which makes it pretty much unusable.

I don't use gfxcardstatus or SMCfancontrol, and it happens on a clean install of Yosemite.

Out of interest, I see you also have the 2.7GHz model. Maybe it's just that CPU that's causing issues? Does anyone with the 2.3 or 2.6GHz machines have the same problem?

My 2.6 GHz mid '12 got replaced because of the same issue. They had my Mac for 2 weeks at the Apple store and couldn't fix it, despite replacing almost every part inside.
 

Brian Y

macrumors 68040
Oct 21, 2012
3,776
1,064
My 2.6 GHz mid '12 got replaced because of the same issue. They had my Mac for 2 weeks at the Apple store and couldn't fix it, despite replacing almost every part inside.

That's strange. There must be something causing a specific subset of them to be going awry. If it was a driver issue, every 2012 one (or indeed, every Mac with graphics switching) would be experiencing it.

Mine had just come back from having a new logic board because of a GPU failure, ironically!
 

kittencounter

macrumors member
Mar 22, 2013
93
0
I stopped using Gfxstatus and everything is fine now. With graphic tools running it will freeze just by browsing certain websites.
 

bkribbs

macrumors 65816
Original poster
Jan 15, 2012
1,178
0
I am sure it is a hardware fault.

My 2012 is being replaced because of this. It's gotten to the point where my machine just freezes and cuts out at least twice per day, which makes it pretty much unusable.

I don't use gfxcardstatus or SMCfancontrol, and it happens on a clean install of Yosemite.

Out of interest, I see you also have the 2.7GHz model. Maybe it's just that CPU that's causing issues? Does anyone with the 2.3 or 2.6GHz machines have the same problem?

It appears to just be driver related.

----------

I stopped using Gfxstatus and everything is fine now. With graphic tools running it will freeze just by browsing certain websites.

I'll try turning it off but I don't imagine that will be the difference.
 

MacInTO

macrumors 65816
Apr 25, 2005
1,195
216
Canada, eh!
My 2012 is being replaced because of this. It's gotten to the point where my machine just freezes and cuts out at least twice per day, which makes it pretty much unusable.

I don't use gfxcardstatus or SMCfancontrol, and it happens on a clean install of Yosemite.

Out of interest, I see you also have the 2.7GHz model. Maybe it's just that CPU that's causing issues? Does anyone with the 2.3 or 2.6GHz machines have the same problem?
I have the 2012 2.7 as well. I've never experienced my machine freezing. At what point or what application(s) are running when it happens?
 

Brian Y

macrumors 68040
Oct 21, 2012
3,776
1,064
I have the 2012 2.7 as well. I've never experienced my machine freezing. At what point or what application(s) are running when it happens?

It can be absolutely anything. Sometimes safari, sometimes it'll do it with nothing running just sitting on the desktop. Running Photoshop is a pretty much guaranteed way to get it to freeze.

Sometimes I get a message about a graphics problem related to an "Intel GPU Hang", other times it just comes back on as normal - checking the console log shows 0 activity during the frozen time.
 

cjmillsnun

macrumors 68020
Aug 28, 2009
2,399
48
It appears to just be driver related.

I really don't think it is. I went back to Mountain Lion (the OS that came with my Mac) and it still did it on a completely clean install.

I ran AHT and it found problems with the SSD. I rang AppleCare who asked me to take it into the Apple Store. They couldn't get it to boot to their internal network when booting using a Thunderbolt ethernet adaptor, so they diagnosed a logic board fault. Subsequent tests using ASD over an external HD, confirmed the logic board was at fault, specifically the GPU.

2 weeks later and despite replacing almost every part they could, it still wasn't fixed and they gave up trying to repair it and replaced the machine for me.

A lot of other people are having this problem, not just on Yosemite, but on Mavericks too.
 

Brian Y

macrumors 68040
Oct 21, 2012
3,776
1,064
I really don't think it is. I went back to Mountain Lion (the OS that came with my Mac) and it still did it on a completely clean install.

I ran AHT and it found problems with the SSD. I rang AppleCare who asked me to take it into the Apple Store. They couldn't get it to boot to their internal network when booting using a Thunderbolt ethernet adaptor, so they diagnosed a logic board fault. Subsequent tests using ASD over an external HD, confirmed the logic board was at fault, specifically the GPU.

2 weeks later and despite replacing almost every part they could, it still wasn't fixed and they gave up trying to repair it and replaced the machine for me.

A lot of other people are having this problem, not just on Yosemite, but on Mavericks too.

I agree - if it was a general driver issue, there would be a much larger percentage of people experiencing issues.

Interestingly, mine failed their test on the GPU too. Maybe it's a batch of faulty chips?
 

bkribbs

macrumors 65816
Original poster
Jan 15, 2012
1,178
0
I really don't think it is. I went back to Mountain Lion (the OS that came with my Mac) and it still did it on a completely clean install.

I ran AHT and it found problems with the SSD. I rang AppleCare who asked me to take it into the Apple Store. They couldn't get it to boot to their internal network when booting using a Thunderbolt ethernet adaptor, so they diagnosed a logic board fault. Subsequent tests using ASD over an external HD, confirmed the logic board was at fault, specifically the GPU.

2 weeks later and despite replacing almost every part they could, it still wasn't fixed and they gave up trying to repair it and replaced the machine for me.

A lot of other people are having this problem, not just on Yosemite, but on Mavericks too.

I agree - if it was a general driver issue, there would be a much larger percentage of people experiencing issues.

Interestingly, mine failed their test on the GPU too. Maybe it's a batch of faulty chips?

There is a thread where there are a lot of people didn't have problems until Yosemite, I never had a freeze until the betas. I'm not convinced. I really like SMS relay but I may downgrade just to see.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.