Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Dronecatcher

macrumors 603
Original poster
Jun 17, 2014
5,238
7,870
Lincolnshire, UK
Was backing up some files (migrating from Mac mini to iMac) and came across this I did last year - how times change, half the "cover stars" have already moved on.

MRMag.jpg
 
Last edited:

floral

macrumors 65816
Jan 12, 2023
1,011
1,234
Earth
Sometimes I wonder why people are so dedicated to PowerPC macs... even the most powerful G5 is obsolete ~20 years later, no?
 

eyoungren

macrumors Penryn
Aug 31, 2011
29,527
28,242
...Oh. I get it, sentimental/historical value...
Or just that it can often be the right tool for the job.

Would you try and play 2000-2006 era games on an M2 Mac? Could you?

How about being a bridge between Intel and 68k Macs?

Some people need to maintain old software because there were no further updates. Some people are quite comfortable using period software for what they do. Can you tell a PDF made from QuarkXPress 6 or InDesisn 2 from one made from QuarkXPress 2023 or ID CS23? What about a Word doc or Excel file made from Word/Excel 2004 or 2008 vs one made from the latest version of Office for Mac? Photoshop or Illustrator file? Aren't PSD and AI similar formats despite upgrades?

And last but not least, there is a generation out there now that seems to value 'distraction free' computers for their tasks. I'm not one of those, but it's a reason some people gravitate to PowerPC now.
 

doctor_dog

macrumors regular
Dec 19, 2022
109
107
This question gets posed a lot it seems. If you're asking seriously, for me it isn't nostalgia at all (I never had one back then), I just really like the hardware. Given text input is such a large part of digital life (especially work), I find keyboard comfort to be one of the highest priorities, which the PPC portables deliver in spades.

Foe instance, a 17" Powerbook is a Cadillac. It types like a dream, it's comfortable to use, and the design aesthetic is incomparable. It has all modern ports I need without the need for dongles (you can debate of course USB revisions and the like). The iBook G4 has, in my mind, also one of the best laptop keyboards ever made. I can't replicate that level of old-school, built-like-a-tank with comfort in 2023 machines (at least not from Apple).
 

floral

macrumors 65816
Jan 12, 2023
1,011
1,234
Earth
Or just that it can often be the right tool for the job.

Would you try and play 2000-2006 era games on an M2 Mac? Could you?

How about being a bridge between Intel and 68k Macs?

Some people need to maintain old software because there were no further updates. Some people are quite comfortable using period software for what they do. Can you tell a PDF made from QuarkXPress 6 or InDesisn 2 from one made from QuarkXPress 2023 or ID CS23? What about a Word doc or Excel file made from Word/Excel 2004 or 2008 vs one made from the latest version of Office for Mac? Photoshop or Illustrator file? Aren't PSD and AI similar formats despite upgrades?

And last but not least, there is a generation out there now that seems to value 'distraction free' computers for their tasks. I'm not one of those, but it's a reason some people gravitate to PowerPC now.
I can see that, but couldn't the majority of those uses be achieved with an early Intel?
 

eyoungren

macrumors Penryn
Aug 31, 2011
29,527
28,242
I can see that, but couldn't the majority of those uses be achieved with an early Intel?
That is an excellent point and not really one I can definitively answer. On the one hand, having lived through the era and being stuck on PowerPC for real paid work I would have much preferred having an Intel Mac at the time.

But on this side of things, I find my 2006 17" MBP to be lacking in the kind of power and usefulness that I would have expected of that era. My MacPro and Mac Minis are certainly far more capable and in 2020 I fully moved on to Intel Macs as my primary Macs.

All that said though, I do entertain plans in my head to, at some point, set up a small 'design' lab using my old PowerPC Macs, particularly my Quad G5. There is an aspect, a 'fun' if you will, side of things that doing design in QXP 8 and ID CS4 adds to the process. I suppose that may be because its simply design for me with no deadlines and no arguments with sales and ad reps. Something I didn't always get back when those were the tools I used for a paycheck.

I can only speak for myself. Others will have different input.
 

doctor_dog

macrumors regular
Dec 19, 2022
109
107
I can see that, but couldn't the majority of those uses be achieved with an early Intel?
You indeed can, my issue with early Intel Macbook Pros is reliability. I had an early Intel, which has most all the positives I ascribe to the PowerBooks and iBooks, but alas it died due to a known hardware issue. This isn't true for all early Intel portables, you just have to be careful not to pick up one with one of the known GPU defects.
 

AphoticD

macrumors 68020
Feb 17, 2017
2,283
3,465
For the Q of “Why PowerPC?” The answer is “Why not?”. Because we can. Same goes for old-school Amiga, Atari and m68k users.

Or like drivers on the road who have yet to embrace EV, and actually enjoy “old technology” such as the rumble of a combustion engine.

Each to their own!
 

HawkTheHusky1902

macrumors 6502a
Jun 26, 2023
666
491
Berlin, Germany
You indeed can, my issue with early Intel Macbook Pros is reliability. I had an early Intel, which has most all the positives I ascribe to the PowerBooks and iBooks, but alas it died due to a known hardware issue. This isn't true for all early Intel portables, you just have to be careful not to pick up one with one of the known GPU defects.
Like my 2013 MBP running Ventura with OCLP flawlessly like native, and doesnt stutter at all and is not affected by gpu problems: )
 
  • Like
Reactions: doctor_dog

Project Alice

macrumors 68020
Jul 13, 2008
2,055
2,139
Post Falls, ID
Oh wow how did I miss this lol

I haven't been on here much either. This is awesome though! I haven't really even screwed around with any of my machines in quite a while either..
 

Project Alice

macrumors 68020
Jul 13, 2008
2,055
2,139
Post Falls, ID
For the Q of “Why PowerPC?” The answer is “Why not?”. Because we can. Same goes for old-school Amiga, Atari and m68k users.

Or like drivers on the road who have yet to embrace EV, and actually enjoy “old technology” such as the rumble of a combustion engine.

Each to their own!
I'll walk before I have an EV. I like my vehicles with an engine, and also, a manual transmission.
 

Certificate of Excellence

macrumors 6502a
Feb 9, 2021
929
1,442
Generally speaking, like my computers, I like cars that I can fix/tweak/adjust most things myself. If I can help it, a car that is analog and does not hook up to OBD-II standard for diagnostic purposes is great. In a mild ironic twist, I don't trust the old computers they interface with lol.

I'm anticipating some entertaining EV early-adopter rants in about 8-10 years when their batteries start failing and they get hit with that 10-15k price tag to replace it. Im not against EV, I do however think there's some big opportunities for refinement in the technology before I am willing to fork out for one.
 

evanboonie

macrumors member
Jul 4, 2020
57
61
Sometimes I wonder why people are so dedicated to PowerPC macs... even the most powerful G5 is obsolete ~20 years later, no?
I think people have a lot of reasons that they use old machines and not all of them are for use as a daily driver. I spend about 80% of my computing time on my M1 MacBook Pro, 18% on my Windows desktop, and maybe 2% on vintage machines (primarily PowerPC macs). I'm interested in them for a few reasons myself. First is that they are quite hackable. I really enjoy learning more about how computers really work by reverse engineering them and making them do things they were never meant to do. I also always wanted PowerPC Macs as a kid but couldn't afford them. These old macs give me a glimpse of an aspect of life I never experienced back then.
 
  • Love
Reactions: AphoticD
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.