Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

tibetanterrier

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Jun 20, 2010
2
0
Indiana
A couple months ago there were a variety of free mp3 download apps available on the app store. They were essentially just basic file download apps with a built in music player similar to the build in music app. These apps are all now gone from the app store, I am assuming have been removed by apple. Anyone know why these would be taken down, because they were very useful.
 
I'm still seeing a lot of them.

Try changing the categories to Music or Utilities or searching 'download'.
 
The "alfadevs free music downloaded" seems to have been pulled. I hope this doesn't signify something ominous about apple becoming more evil.

----------

This one is still there:

https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/downloads-downloader-download/id343307433?mt=8
 
I just looked, and some of them are removed!! It's just Apple teaching us that even though you have a completely locked down OS, there's always something you can do to lock it down even more! Soon enough you'll see all the Wallpaper apps disappear ;)
 
A couple months ago there were a variety of free mp3 download apps available on the app store. They were essentially just basic file download apps with a built in music player similar to the build in music app. These apps are all now gone from the app store, I am assuming have been removed by apple. Anyone know why these would be taken down, because they were very useful.

Well let me think... maybe because iTunes is a legal revenue stream for music producers and powers iTunes, and because MP3s can be pirated, and apps that allow MP3 downloads would bypass iTunes?

Just me pondering the obvious...
 
I just looked, and some of them are removed!! It's just Apple teaching us that even though you have a completely locked down OS, there's always something you can do to lock it down even more! Soon enough you'll see all the Wallpaper apps disappear ;)

Mp3 sharing for free = illegal and people actually go to jail for that in the US

Wallpaper apps = legal
 
They always get pulled sooner or later. That has been the case for many years now. In general, you are free to submit an app that does act as a downloader, hence SoundCloud and others exist. But most of these music downloaders that do get pulled, is because of DCMA takedown notices from someone else.
 
I just looked, and some of them are removed!! It's just Apple teaching us that even though you have a completely locked down OS, there's always something you can do to lock it down even more! Soon enough you'll see all the Wallpaper apps disappear ;)

Apple is smarter than you think. The last thing they need right now is a Law suit from the record industry because an "app" on the appstore is distributing music content without proper licensing.
 
Apple is smarter than you think. The last thing they need right now is a Law suit from the record industry because an "app" on the appstore is distributing music content without proper licensing.

Trust me, the Apple would be the last people to get talked to by the record industry. Look at all the pirating music sites on the internet. None of them have been caught yet. But I see your point, Apple would rather be safe than sorry
 
Trust me, the Apple would be the last people to get talked to by the record industry. Look at all the pirating music sites on the internet. None of them have been caught yet. But I see your point, Apple would rather be safe than sorry

None of them have been caught?? I think can think of a few file sharing sites that have!
 
Whoa. This has been a real eye-opener. I guess my 8 month experiment going from Android to iOS has been worth it, because this little incident, finally demonstrates why a locked down ecosystem is not for me. Never Again.

There is certainly no iPhone 6 in my future. Nor a new iPad miniretina.

Well that saves me a bunch of money doesn't' it.


Cya apple.

I'll hang around these forums I guess a few more months until I figure out which new phone I'll get to replace my iPhone 5 and 5s, but that's it. ***** YOU APPLE.
 
Whoa. This has been a real eye-opener. I guess my 8 month experiment going from Android to iOS has been worth it, because this little incident, finally demonstrates why a locked down ecosystem is not for me. Never Again.

There is certainly no iPhone 6 in my future. Nor a new iPad miniretina.

Well that saves me a bunch of money doesn't' it.


Cya apple.

I'll hang around these forums I guess a few more months until I figure out which new phone I'll get to replace my iPhone 5 and 5s, but that's it. ***** YOU APPLE.
Cool story. :apple:
 
They also made apps remove the ability to cache youtube videos, so if you have any apps that do that don't update or delete them ;D
 
Free mp3 download apps removed from app store?

They always get pulled sooner or later. That has been the case for many years now. In general, you are free to submit an app that does act as a downloader, hence SoundCloud and others exist. But most of these music downloaders that do get pulled, is because of DCMA takedown notices from someone else.


The SoundCloud app doesn't download. It just streams. As long as I can remember with the SoundCloud app, it has been streaming only.

----------

They also made apps remove the ability to cache youtube videos, so if you have any apps that do that don't update or delete them ;D


Google probably requested it. It is against YouTube's terms of service to download videos from YouTube, not Apple's.
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.